The Air Force could get the same or better space tracking without building on sacred land. Five main alternatives exist.
The alternatives
- Mount Hopkins, Arizona. At 8,553 feet in the Santa Rita Mountains, with frequent clear nights, strong atmospheric quality for tracking, and existing research facilities including the MMT and Whipple Observatory.
- White Sands, New Mexico. Already home to the 15th Space Surveillance Squadron and existing Air Force Detachment 1 infrastructure — an established site that tracks objects in orbit today.
- Kitt Peak, Arizona. At 6,883 feet, home to Kitt Peak National Observatory and radio-telescope infrastructure, with proven tracking capability on the continent.
- Cerro Pachón, Chile. Home to the Gemini South and SOAR telescopes and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory, with atmospheric conditions better than Haleakalā’s.
- Las Campanas, Chile. A high-elevation site with existing global tracking infrastructure, exceptional viewing, and far less cultural conflict than Maui.
- Space-based systems. Satellites that watch other satellites have no atmospheric interference, global coverage, and can react in minutes rather than days.
What the law requires
Federal law requires the Air Force to seriously study alternatives: feasibility studies, objective comparisons of capability, cost-benefit analysis, and written proof if an alternative truly will not work. The coalition says the continental and international sites were dismissed without that analysis.
Based on the work of our partners at the Protect Haleakalā Coalition. See the original at ProtectHaleakala.com.
