Legal Analysis

Why the AMOS STAR review falls short of federal law.

NEPA: alternatives are the heart of the review

  • NEPA requires agencies to rigorously explore and objectively evaluate all reasonable alternatives. Courts call this the heart of an environmental impact statement.
  • The Air Force mentioned continental U.S. sites but rejected them with brief references to “operational requirements.”
  • There was no technical analysis of alternative sites, no cost-benefit comparison, and no environmental evaluation of them.
  • The outcome appears to have been decided in advance.
  • When a project significantly affects unique resources such as sacred sites, NEPA requires a thorough look at avoiding those impacts.

Section 106: avoid first, mitigate last

  • Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act directs agencies to avoid, minimize, or mitigate harm to historic properties — in that order.
  • Avoidance is the primary requirement; mitigation is the last resort.
  • By not seriously exploring other locations, the Air Force skipped straight to mitigation.
  • Courts treat cursory dismissal of alternatives as a violation, especially where Traditional Cultural Properties are involved.

Based on the work of our partners at the Protect Haleakalā Coalition. See the original at ProtectHaleakala.com.