The Record: Community Voices

More than 80 people testified against AMOS STAR at the February 2026 hearings in Kīhei and Pukalani. Their voices must not be forgotten.

What the community said

  • Land title and sovereignty: testifiers challenged title to the lands and the annexation record, recalling the 1893 overthrow.
  • The environment: water and aquifers, the East Maui watershed, ʻuaʻu nesting sites, and trash and maintenance problems at the summit.
  • Cultural and spiritual harm: sacred sites, ancestral connections, and the summit as a piko.
  • Process: the EIS is inadequate, consultation has been a checkbox, and the community’s words have been misrepresented.
  • Military ties: objections to links with defense contractors and military use.

Voices from the hearings

  • Lisa Galloway said the spill came from poor maintenance, not the lightning strike the public was told about.
  • Paul Garrett Hugel said the draft EIS does not meaningfully assess the summit’s cultural and spiritual significance.
  • Keani Rollins Fernandez said the telescopes could work at sea level, and that the military’s presence makes the islands a target.
  • Kanealiʻi Williams said consultation must happen with each family, not by ticking a box at a forum.
  • Kalamaehu Takahashi and Ariana Lawrence said there is no clear title to the lands, and no middle ground.
  • Sarah Tekula said the summit feeds the East Maui watershed, the island’s largest source of water.
  • A testifier noted that no survey of ʻuaʻu nesting sites was done at the proposed telescope locations.
  • Richard Ho said 150 years of aloha have been taken for granted, and the right number of new telescopes is zero.
  • Dick Mayer urged federal, state and county agencies to work together on a full master plan for the summit.
  • Kamehameha Pūlimi said he should not have to keep fighting battles that should have been settled generations ago.

Read and verify the testimony, and see photos from both hearings, at ProtectHaleakala.com/the-record.

Based on the work of our partners at the Protect Haleakalā Coalition. See the original at ProtectHaleakala.com.