Author: fueji

  • Haleakala telescope offers no direct benefits, desecrates a sacred place

    By KIOPE RAYMOND

    June 21, 2009

    The summit area of Haleakala does not have a comprehensive, community-driven, scientifically based and culturally appropriate management plan.

    A partial list of Haleakala summit users would include 1.7 million annual visitors to Haleakala National Park; National Park Service employees; staff of Coast Guard communication towers, TV and phone towers; the UH Institute for Astronomy, its lessees and partners; commercial activity businesses and Native Hawaiian practitioners.

    As a result, individual entities, like the Institute for Astronomy, have their own long-range plans for development. Without a comprehensive plan for the summit area, inappropriate projects like the construction of the 143-foot, 14-story Advanced Technology Solar Telescope on the summit of Haleakala can be developed on separate parcels that have adverse impact on the whole.

    If one wanted to build a 14-story hotel on Maui, it would not be allowed! If one wanted to build a 14-story public education complex on Maui, it would not be allowed! If one wanted to build a 14-story structure to house the houseless on Maui, it would not be allowed!

    Yet, we would allow the construction of a 14-story observatory that will top out at approximately 10,123 feet – 100 feet higher than the highest point on the island – within a summit area that has no comprehensive master plan; that is acknowledged to be a sacred place; that is on what the state says are 18 acres of ceded lands which accrue just $1 per annum, therefore just 20 cents pro rata share for the benefit of Native Hawaiians in rent from the Institute for Astronomy to the state of Hawaii; that is going to need an additional Maui Electric substation and power for the equivalent of 4,000 homes; and is, lest we forget, on state conservation district land.

    A fallacious argument is made that because Hawaiians revered astronomy, then anything done in the 21st century with respect to astronomy is automatically consistent with Hawaiian spirituality. It’s like saying because Hawaiians revere kalo and because a company wants to genetically modify kalo they’re actually not at cross purposes – they both have proper respect for kalo, they’re just looking at it differently. That logic is unacceptable!

    It is also unacceptable logic that infers that during the 19th century period of Hawaiian monarchy, Kalakaua introduced telescopes to Hawaii and he would be – and we should be – in favor of the ATST. Well, Kalakaua also introduced electricity to Hawaii. Shouldn’t we, by the same logic, light up Maui – or at least the top of Haleakala – at night with electric lights? Of course not!

    The proximity – less than 100 feet – of the 14-story structure during six or more years’ construction phase and then at least 50 more years of planned existence to a place of worship is painful to those who want to offer respectful prayer. It is a place of spiritual epiphany. It is even more painful to those who want to practice Hawaiian religious ceremonies with offerings to Hawaiian deities to see the desecration of digging into the rock, a kino lau or physical manifestation of the goddess Pele, and the possible loss, or “incidental take,” of ‘ua’u. The petrel is considered an ‘aumakua, or family ancestral spirit.

    When I recall the mo’olelo of Maui snaring the sun, I remember that Maui’s act had direct benefit for his own family and to all Hawaiians. I respectfully doubt and question the direct benefit to all Hawaiians and residents of Maui that is derived from the construction of the proposed ATST.

    The supplemental draft environmental impact statement public comment period ends June 22. The final EIS is currently scheduled to be finished in late summer or fall. During a 30-day period thereafter, in addition to an internal final review, the public and other agencies can comment on the final EIS prior to final action on the proposal. The DLNR Conservation District Use application 180-day permit process and public hearings are currently scheduled for this winter and next spring. More information on this issue can be obtained at www.karenchun.com/storedsites/kilakilahaleakala.org/ and atst.nso.edu.

    * Kiope Raymond, a Native Hawaiian, is a tenured associate professor of Hawaiian language and culture at Maui Community College and president of the nonprofit Kilakila o Haleakala, which works to protect the sanctity of the mountain. He lives in Waiohuli.

    hikers on haleakala

  • Kilakila Testimony

    June 5, 2009
    Craig Foltz, Ph.D
    ATST Program Manager
    National Science Foundation
    Division of Astronomical Sciences
    4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 1045
    Arlington VA, 22230

    Office of Environmental Quality Control
    235 S. Beretania St. #702
    Honolulu HI 96813

    Mike Mayberry
    Associate Director
    University of Hawai`i Institute for Astronomy
    34 Ohia Ku St.
    Pukalani HI 96748

    Charlie Fein, Ph.D.
    KC Environmental Inc.
    P.O. Box 1208
    Makawao HI 96768

    Dear officials,

    RE: SDEIS FOR ATST

    Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the National Science Foundation’s Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the proposed Advanced Technology Solar Telescope at Haleakala. These comments are submitted on behalf of Kilakila `O Haleakala. Kilakila `O Haleakala requests a hard copy of the Final Environmental Impact Statement as well as a CD version when it is completed.

    CULTURAL IMPACT

    Environmental Justice

    1. The adverse impact on Native Hawaiian traditional and customary practices is thedefining environmental justice issue for this project. Curiously, the applicant completely ignores this issue in discussing the topic of environmental justice (pages 3-67 and section 4.12). The United States Environmental Protection Agency definesenvironmental justice as the “fair treatment for people of all races, cultures, and incomes, regarding the development of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.” This is premised on the belief that particular segments of society, such as Native Hawaiians, may sometimes bear a disproportionate amount of risk associated with environmental degradation. According to EPA’s “Final Guidance For Incorporating Environmental Justice Concerns in EPA’s NEPA Compliance Analyses” (April 1998):

    In the case of activities potentially affecting Native Americans, potential impacts, both direct and indirect, can occur to sacred sites and/or other natural resources used for cultural purposes. For example, the loss of a sacred site, or other impacts to larger areas of religious and spiritual importance may be so absolute that religious use of the site abruptly ceases–a direct impact.

    Native Hawaiians – a native people who are a minority in their own land – depend on the preservation of natural resources in order to perpetuate their culture. The SDEIS discloses that the area “is a very sacred place for the Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawaiian), past and present.” (p.3-7). The desecration of sacred sites interferes with cultural practices and unfairly targets the Native Hawaiian community. The ATST would, therefore, disproportionately affect – adversely – the Native Hawaiian population. This part of the EIS must be revised to highlight the environmental injustice of ATST.

    Magnitude of impact

    2. The SDEIS identifies four levels of effects (major, moderate, minor and negligible), but fails to clearly explain the severity of the impact of the project on cultural resources. It breaks up different elements of the project, sometimes defining the impact, sometimes avoiding a description (or relying upon qualifying phrases), and sometimes referring to mitigation to some (but not all) the elements.

    3. On the one hand, the SDEIS states on pages ES-33 and 4-10 that “the overwhelmingevidence from a cultural and traditional standpoint points toward a major, adverse and long-term effect on some Native Hawaiian traditional cultural practices and beliefs.” See also, page 4-14. Similarly, on page 4-131, the SDEIS states, “the cumulative effects on cultural and historic resources of the proposed ATST Project combined with past, present and reasonably foreseeable future actions is considered major, adverse, and long-term. On the other hand, it also states that “the cumulative effects on cultural and historic resources of the proposed ATST Project combined with past, present and reasonably foreseeable future actions is considered moderate, adverse and long-term” (page ES-47); see also page 4-179. Clearly page ES-47 is in error. Cumulative impactsinclude the direct impacts and so could not possibly be less than “major.” Similarly, the impact on cultural practices is called “minor” on page ES-33.

    4. The FEIS should fully and clearly disclose whether the following elements of the project would have a “major” or “moderate” adverse impact on cultural resources and activities:

    • the construction activities associated with building the ATST (including excavation, noise and visual);
    • the existence of a 143-foot structure at Kolekole (visual);
    • the noise generated from the operation of the ATST and associated activities; and
    • the operation of the ATST, including maintenance, repairs and personnel turn-over.

    5. The SDEIS clearly states that the repairs and turnover in operations “would have amajor, adverse, and long-term effect on cultural resources” (p. 4-9). It fails, however, to clearly state that the construction activities, the existence of the massive structure, and the noise generated by the operations would have a major adverse and long term adverse effect on cultural resources. This analysis is critical because, while the applicant alleges that “implementation of mitigation measures would reduce the effect intensity to a moderate adverse, long-term level for these types of adverse impacts to cultural resources,” these mitigation measures have absolutely nothing to do with the impact caused by, for example, the ATST’s massive presence.

    6. The SDEIS on the one hand states that “the amount of noise and construction-related activities associated with the proposed ATST Project would have a major, adverse and short-term effect,” but then concludes, without any real discussion, that certain restrictions reduce the impacts to “minor” (p. 4-10). What analysis allows the applicant to reach this conclusion? Curiously, on page 4-10, the SDEIS suggests that noise-generating activities such as construction would be restricted from 30 minutes prior to sunset and 30 minutes after sunrise. On page 4-78, however, the SDEIS reveals thatonly those construction activities exceeding 83 dBA noise levels would be restricted. Thus, Native Hawaiians engaged in traditional and customary activities near the ATST would be subjected to noise levels of up to 82 dBA at sunrise and sunset. How does that change a major effect into a minor one?

    Mitigation

    7. How does providing “sense of place” training mitigate the pain and loss suffered by Native Hawaiian traditional and customary practitioners in any way, shape or form?

    8. How does such training mitigate the visual impact? the noise? How is the cultural specialist going to make the project quieter, or make the buildings more invisible?

    9. The Final Environmental Impact Statement must include a clear explanation as to how providing “sense of place” training to personnel could possibly mitigate damage to a sacred site.

    10. It is entirely unclear how the mitigation measures actually will reduce the impact on traditional and cultural practices to minor effects rather than major (p. 4-14) – particularly when the mitigation measures do not mitigate the massive structure or the damage done to a sacred site.

    11. Pursuant to federal law “mitigation” is defined as

    (a) Avoiding the impact altogether by not taking a certain action or parts of an action.

    (b) Minimizing impacts by limiting the degree or magnitude of the action and its implementation.

    (c) Rectifying the impact by repairing, rehabilitating, or restoring the affected environment.

    (d) Reducing or eliminating the impact over time by preservation and maintenance operations during the life of the action.

    (e) Compensating for the impact by replacing or providing substitute resources or environments.

    40 CFR § 1508.20. State law uses the term in the same manner. HAR § 11-200-17( M). It appears, however, that the NSF has adopted a bizarre new definition of the term “mitigation”. The NSF fails to discuss how it could avoid these impacts, minimize the impacts, rectify the impacts (by restoring the affected environment), reduce the impacts, or compensate by providing substitute resources. Instead, NSF proposes spending money on items that have nothing to do with the cultural harm whatsoever. These educational “public benefits” do not qualify as mitigation.

    Who Should Compromise?

    12. On November 8, 2007, NSF Assistant General Counsel Caroline Blanco wrote in a letter to the Advisory Counsel [sic] for Historic Preservation that “there can be no minimization of the adverse effects that result from the location of the proposed ATST project.” She also wrote, “NSF takes the position that the anticipated adverse effects expressed by the Native Hawaiian community cannot be minimized.” In discussing alternative sites, the SDEIS makes it clear that certain scientific objectives cannot be compromised. Substantial and irrevocable reductions in scientific output are unacceptable. In fact, there are no elements in the actual ATST project that the NSF is willing to compromise on, including size, color, location, etc. Not one. Why then are substantial and irrevocable impacts to existing cultural practices of a native people acceptable? Why is it unacceptable for the NSF to compromise its objective – and yet acceptable to insist that Native Hawaiians compromise their practices and values and accept further desecration of their sacred religious sites in order to accommodate NSF’s demands to build a new facility on Maui?

    13. How does the NSF define arrogance?

    NOISE

    14. The suggestion that there “are no noise-sensitive human receptors at HO, such as . . . land uses where people generally expect and need a quiet environment” (pages ES-26 and 3-59) is absurd. Native Hawaiians who exercise traditional and customary practices at Haleakala are, to use the bureaucratic term, “noise-sensitive human receptors.” Given the sanctity of Haleakala, all new noise sources will adversely affect the natural soundscape and are inappropriate.

    15. The assumption that only noise levels changes of above 20 dBA are “major” has absolutely no support in the scientific literature regarding noise. There must be some basis for using 20 dBA as a criterion (p. 4-99) – although it appears that the applicant has arbitrarily decided that the number 20 is a magic number (see the use of the magic number 20 in the discussion of visual effects on page 4-30).

    16. In a natural setting like Haleakala National Park, any industrial or mechanical noise is an unnatural intrusion and has a major adverse affect. The noise analysis ignores frequency, unnaturalness, intensity and duration of noise generation.

    17. To say that the sound attenuation of industrial noises at 35 dBA is “the equivalent of leaves rustling or wind blowing through the grass” (p. 4-100) is insulting.

    18. The discussion regarding the noise impacts of the operation of the ATST and its related facilities is inadequate. Simply because the noise levels would be below levels for Class A zoning districts does not mean that the facility would not generate new noise. How much noise will the buildings, the fans, the air conditioners, rotational tracking, generator etc. generate?

    19. Noise should be anticipated during construction anddecommissioning/deconstruction.

    20. The real question that the FEIS must address is: how far away would a person have to be from the ATST facility to be sure that the person did not hear any (a) construction noise and (b) operational noise. This is the most important question for the FEIS to address regarding noise because, given the location, any such new noise source will have a major adverse effect.

    VISUAL IMPACTS

    21. The quantitative methodology is ridiculous. Unless one is very, very close to a structure, according to this methodology, the structure will only impact a small percentage of a view plane. To claim that a major scenic impact can only be from a structure that affects more than 20% of a viewplane renders virtually all construction impacts from any real distance non-major. Thus, a large crane on top of Mount Rushmore would not have a major scenic adverse impact. A house on the rim of the Grand Canyon would not have a major adverse scenic impact. Adding just one brush-stroke of fluorescent purple paint to the Mona Lisa would not have a major adverse impact. The reality is, a large man-made object that intrudes upon a natural landscape in the massive scale proposed by ATST cannot help but have a major adverse impact on views.

    22. The applicant should instead employ the methodology articulated by the State of Hawai`i Department of Land and Natural Resources in its decision In re: HECO’s CDUA to Construct a 138-kV Transmission Line at Wa`ahila Ridge, DLNR File No. OA-2801. The transmission towers at issue in that case did not occupy anywhere close to 20% of the viewshed, yet their impact was significant enough to warrant rejecting a conservation district use application.

    23. The visual simulations do not fairly depict the visual blight that the structure will be on Haleakala. Just as photographs of the observatories on Mauna Kea do not accurately show the pimples that blight the mountain top, figures 4-5 – 4-16 do not capture what can be seen and what will be seen.

    24. Even the IFA’s Long Range Development Plan does a better job of acknowledging the impact. It states:

    The ATST will be a large facility compared to the current Mees Solar Observatory. The top of the telescope enclosure may be as much as 142 feet or more above ground level. If sited at either the present MSO location (Figure 8-9) or Reber Circle (Figure 8-7), the white telescope enclosure would be quite visible from the Red Hill Overlook and on cloud-free days it could be visible from South Maui and the Central Valley, although it would be blocked in some directions by the AEOS facility.

    25. The ATST would impede the view plane from mountain to ocean, ruin the character of the natural surrounding and ruin essential vistas.

    26. Tall cranes will be required during construction anddecommissioning/deconstruction.

    27. When the SDEIS states that the ATST “would not be fully visible” (p. 4-62) does that mean that the entire structure is not visible, or that it is not visible along the entire roadway? In either case, what difference does it make if it is not “fully visible”? If it is only a part of it is visible, or if it is only seen part of the drive, it still detracts from the quality of the area and is out of characte

    r of the natural surrounding.

    SECTION 4.1 ON “LAND USE” MAKES NO SENSE.

    28. Section 4.1 of the SDEIS is bizarre. It appears to analyze the ATST’s impact on “land use.” Grammatically and logically it is hard to understand how a project impacts “land use.” Projects impact people, the environment, infrastructure etc. They also change the use of land. The applicant has created a strawman by arguing that the ATST has no effect on land use. The application of the regulatory definition of “land use” in HAR § 13-5 further muddies the applicant’s “analysis.” The real questions for this section of the SDEIS should be: is the ATST compatible with existing land use designations, and will it affect existing land uses and existing activities? Section 4.1 utterly fails to engage in this analysis, however.

    29. Curiously, the applicant ignores the BLNR’s criteria (except for a select two) for evaluating a CDUP found in HAR § 13-5-30. There is no doubt that the applicant’s proposal fails to satisfy these criteria and that it will not be able to obtain a CDUP.

    ALTERNATIVES

    30. The discussion in the two paragraphs above section 2.3.3 (page 2-7) is clearly inaccurate. The discussion dismisses the alternative of building a space-based telescope with a series of non-sequitors and misleading statements. First, it is contradicted on page 1-11 where the SDEIS states that it is cost that precludes this possibility – not technological obstacles. Second, objectives 1, 2 and 3 – ostensibly the reason for rejecting sites at La Palma and Big Bear – could certainly be achieved by a space-based telescope. Third, scientific advances have already achieved the predictive power for coronal mass ejections that could jeopardize global communication. Fourth, the role of this telescope in reducing the “risk for human civilization” is ridiculous hyperbole. Finally, given that “the most highly variable parts of the Sun’s spectrum are found in the UV and X-ray region” (page 1-17) and given the fact that study of UV and X-ray wavelengths from a land-based station would be ineffective (given the atmosphere), would not a space-based telescope make more sense?

    31. Is cost the reason that a space-based telescope was rejected, or are technological limits the reason it was not chosen?

    32. Could a space-based telescope achieve all the scientific objectives?

    33. If so, how much more would it cost?

    34. The SDEIS presents evidence that locating the telescope at Haleakala would be better than elsewhere (from the perspective of efficiency). The SDEIS can, in fairness, argue that Haleakala offers more “seeing” hours than other sites. Or it could argue that it “represents the best combination of [astronomical] factors” (Appendix J p. 1) But it cannot credibly argue that Haleakala is the “only” place where such a telescope can be located. It is absurd for the applicant to proclaim that there is a bright-line below which any other site would utterly fail to meet the “scientific objectives” of the project. The applicant is free to argue that Haleakala offers more sunshine or more seeing hours. But the applicant cannot credibly claim that other sites would completely fail to achieve the scientific objectives. The applicant subjectively developed what it terms “unacceptable levels of hours for high quality observations” (p. 2-16). There is no objective reason why the telescope must have 480 annual hours of sky brightness less than 25 millionths of the brightness of the solar disk – and not one minute less. There is no objective reason why the telescope must have 200 annual hours of excellent seeing.

    35. Since March 2008 emissions from Kilauea on Hawai`i Island have increased dramatically. Combined with the numerous periods of no tradewinds, atmospheric conditions on Maui are no longer what they used to be. According to the USGS, since this latest eruption phase, Kilauea is currently producing up to 4,000 tons/day of SO2, — far more than the 150 tons per day it used to produce. During its journey through the air, the SO2 reacts with oxygen, sunlight, and water to form vog, a mixture of gas and tiny sulfuric acid aerosol droplets. This aerosol mixture appears as a dense haze that obscures Hawaiian scenery and ocean views. Has the applicant re-examined its data to see if Haleakala still meets all the criteria it needs for solar observation?

    WASTEWATER & HAZARDOUS WASTE

    36. The FEIS should disclose what impacts –if any – the current cesspool has on groundwater. If the FEIS is going to claim that replacement of it will provide minor – not negligible – benefits, it should fully disclose what the impacts of the current operation are.

    37. If the aquifer is vulnerable to contamination from wastewater (as mentioned on page ES-23), then the threat posed by the existing cesspool operated by IFA should be fully described.

    38. If wastewater is a threat, the FEIS should disclose why the ATST does not propose an even higher level of treatment prior to disposal.

    39. Simply because a wastewater system meets State of Hawai`i Department of Health regulatory standards does not mean that it will have no impact – especially when the aquifer is “highly vulnerable to contamination” (p. ES-23). The FEIS should fully discuss the impacts of existing and increased wastewater discharge.

    40. The FEIS should more fully discuss the potential impacts of hazardous waste being disposed through the wastewater system or on the ground, including all the chemicals described on page 2-36. Given the September 11, 1999 spill incident (page ES-24), such accidents are entirely foreseeable. The FEIS should disclose the likely impacts from another accident. The fact that a response to a spill may meet legal requirements does not explain the impacts to the aquifer or the larger ecosystem.

    EXCAVATION

    41. At La Palma, excavation of 9,000 cubic yards was deemed “considerable” (p. 2-10). Is the removal of 4,650 cubic yards of soil and rock on Haleakala a considerable amount?

    42. How deep and wide would the pit be that would have to be created?

    ELECTRICITY

    43. Why are MECO’s existing rate-payers paying to study ways to reduce the peak proposed ATST Project electrical load (economizing strategies) and not NSF (pages ES-13 & ES-41)?

    44. Who will pay for the upgrading of the new 2500 kVA substation: MECO ratepayers or ATST (page ES-40)?

    THE CONSERVATION DISTRICT

    The applicant makes a series of misleading statements regarding the conservation district.

    45. On pages ES-15, 1-29 and 3-2, the applicant puts two facts together to create a misleading impression. It may in fact be true that the parcel of land at issue was set aside for astronomical research. It is true that the Haleakala High Altitude Observatories are in the conservation district. It is not accurate, however, to imply that (1) the purpose of the conservation district, or this part of the conservation district, is for astronomy or (2) this area has been designated for astronomical research pursuant to Act 187 or the conservation district rules. The executive order setting land aside hasnothing to do with the regulatory restrictions on uses in the conservation district.

    46. Similarly, on page 3-1, the applicant states: “During the past few years, the DLNR’s Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands (OCCL) has administered Conservation District Use Applications (CDUAs) for: open ocean aquaculture projects, telescopes on top of Haleakala and Mauna Kea, major powerline projects on scenic ridges, telecommunication facility projects, single family residences, Parks; and Commercial Forest projects.” The applicant uses the vague term “administered.” Yes, OCCL has received applications for various projects. But the Board of Land and Natural Resources, in fact, rejected the application (the only application) for a major powerline project on a scenic ridge. It rejected the koa logging project proposed on Hawai`i Island. And the court overturned the BLNR’s approval of a CDUP for a telescope on Mauna Kea. The SDEIS, therefore, misleads by suggesting that in “administering” these applications, approval is routine.

    47. The applicant’s explanation for how this project satisfies the objectives of the general subzone (p. 3-2) makes absolutely no sense.

    48. Curiously, the applicant ignores the BLNR’s criteria (except for a select two) for evaluating a CDUP found in HAR § 13-5-30. There is no doubt that the applicant’s proposal fails to satisfy these criteria (let alone state constitutional mandates) and that it will not be able to obtain a CDUP.

    CUMULATIVE IMPACTS

    49. The applicant failed to discuss other EAs and EISes for projects in the area. These documents can demonstrate whether: (a) the applicant and other users of the area accurately predicted impacts; (b) the applicant and other users of the area followed through on prior promises; and (c) proposed mitigation was effective. This analysis is necessary to perform a credible analysis of the cumulative impacts of this project.

    50. For example, in 1994, the IFA stated:

    The proposed facility, approximately 120 feet above grade, would be the largest structure on the upper portions of Haleakala. However, it would be generally consistent with the existing structures, and it would not greatly alter the general appearance of the complex as seen from a distance. The proposed facilities would be clearly visible from the Pakaoao Visitor Center and Red Hill Overlook, where the height and mass of the proposed telescope dome enclosure would make it strong visual element under certain conditions. The visual impact of the telescope dome would be mitigated by its reflective surface. This type of surface tends to take on the color of the sky, and does not stand out strongly, In addition, its proximity to the existing observatory structures that are readily recognizable as telescope housings would indicate the scientific purpose of the entire complex.

    Despite IFA’s assurances, the Air Force’s large AECOS facility (a) is not consistent with the existing structures; (b) greatly altered the appearance of the complex; (c) was not mitigated by its reflective surface; and (d) stands out strongly.

    51. There is no question that the cumulative visual impact of the ATST and past projects is major.

    52. The March 1994 Final EA for the AECOS telescope notes that “at some later date, the 8-meter telescope and dome enclosure will be installed to replace the 3.67-meter telescope.” Has this been done? If not, has this cumulative impact been assessed?

    53. In March 1994, the IFA noted that the enormous AECOS facility would be built to address the Air Force’s “requirements into the 21st century.” An upgrade to a larger telescope is needed to retain MSSS’s usefulness. The need for a better telescope is the same justification for this project a decade later. Given the IFA’s constant refrain that it needs to keep up with the latest technology, when does it all end? When will what is built ever be enough to satisfy the IFA?

    54. Why is there no discussion in the cumulative impacts section regarding the previous damage to cultural resources caused by development in the Haleakala High Altitude Observatory Site? The Air Force development removed rocks from the summit and destroyed an area that was used for worship.

    55. If the ATST project will adversely affect the FAA RCAG facilities, as suggested on page 4-5, and if addressing “any potential issue involving a degradation of signal” will require other construction, then the FEIS must fully disclose this construction and the impacts. Could resolution of the issue include building bigger unsightly towers? Failure to thoroughly discuss this issue is a failure to properly disclose the cumulative impact (i.e., reasonably foreseeable future actions). The applicant may not segment this disclosure through a separate NEPA compliance document as it suggests that it will do on page 4-6.

    OPPORTUNITY COSTS

    56. How much money is this project slated to cost?

    57. What projects are the NSF not funding (and what scientific questions are not being answered) by funding this project? Identify the projects that NSF could potentially (or would) fund if it decided to forego this project.

    58. Clearly the money spent on this project would be an irreversible and irretrievable commitment of a resource that should be discussed in section 4.16.2.

    MITIGATION

    59. Is NSF committing to decommissioning/deconstruction – or just to considering it?

    60. What authority would the “cultural specialist” have? Will s/he merely be able to provide advice that does not have to be followed?

    61. If the `ua`u are present from February through October, why does the mitigation not include all those months? Is there any mitigation from noise when the `ua`u return to their nests in the evening (when apparently construction activities may continue) in February, March, August and September?

    OTHER

    62. The table summarizing the effects from the proposed ATST Project, which is promised on page ES-45, does not exist. Moreover, the four-sentence discussion in section 4.15 (Summary of Potential Effects of the Proposed ATST Project) of the SDEIS is incomplete and inadequate.

    63. A map that shows the Crater Historic District, listed both on the State Inventory of Historic Places (SIHP 50-50-11-12-1739) as well as the National Register of Historic Places should be included in the FEIS.

    64. How will the facility handle all the energy from the sun that is concentrated through the 4 meter array?

    65. How much bicycle traffic is there at the project site (BMP 7 on p. 2-33)?

    66. At various places, the DSEIS mentions that BMPs will be implemented. (see, e.g., pages ES-11, p. ES-54). The specific BMPs should be identified in detail in the mitigation section.

    67. The conclusions of the ATST Survey are obviously flawed. By only asking whether participants “cared” if there was another telescope without directly asking how it would affect their experience, the survey provides no meaningful data.

    68. The FEIS needs to address the impact that may be caused by the increasing number of tourists (as asserted by the applicant) who will want to tour the ATST facility on the tranquility of the area and on Native Hawaiian traditional and customary practices.

    All these issues should be thoroughly addressed in the FEIS.

    Sincerely,

    David Kimo Frankel
    Camille K. Kalama
    Staff Attorneys
    cc: Laura Thielen
    Senator Daniel Akaka
    Congressman Neil Abercrombie
    Congresswoman Mazie Hirono
    Haleakala National Park Service Superintendent
    Sam Lemmo
    Pua Aiu

  • ‘House of the Sun’ getting crowded

    PUKALANI – For nearly a decade, the “line in the lava” – as Kahu Charles Kauluwehi Maxwell Sr. put it
    recently – has been clearly delineated over the National Science Foundation’s proposed 143-foot-tall solar telescope near the summit of Haleakala.

    Native cultural preservationists and Haleakala purists oppose the $161 million Advanced Technology Solar Telescope as sacrilegious, unnecessary and flat-out insensitive and ugly.

    Meanwhile, astronomers and others view it not only as an opportunity to expand the world’s nascent knowledge about the sun, but as a pragmatic tool to help predict and prepare for disasters caused here and in orbit by
    radioactive “coronal mass ejections” that disable electronics and endanger the lives of astronauts and air travelers.

    But the heat now is on both sides to make some of their final arguments in the saga.

    The National Science Foundation’s board of directors is finally expected to decide whether to give the project the go-ahead by the end of this year, said Mike Maberry from the University of Hawaii Institute for Astronomy’s Maikalani Advanced Technology Research Center in Pukalani.

    The federal government is accepting comments until June 22 for a supplemental draft environmental impact statement that was published this month for the telescope. The observatory would be built on less than an acre within the 18-acre UH Institute for Astronomy-managed Science City site.

    Once the comments are collected and a series of public meetings are hosted on Maui next month by project sponsors, such as UH, the National Science Foundation, which is a federal agency, must complete a final environmental impact statement in order to comply with the law.

    Maberry said that construction could begin as early as fall 2010 and would last about four years. The NSA and its National Solar Observatory branch would spend about $75 million during construction on local labor and materials.

    The solar telescope would hire 35 people permanently, most of whom would be Mauians, Maberry said, and it would pump $18 million annually into the local economy.

    At just over 10,000 feet high and located in the Pacific Ocean on Earth’s most isolated archipelago, Haleakala and the Big Island’s Mauna Kea are revered by astronomers for their predictable and mild weather patterns as well as clean and clear views of the atmosphere and space.

    Science City is home to about a dozen observatories and numerous large and small telescopes, some of which
    are owned by the U.S. Air Force and remain top secret. UH owns most of them, though.

    The 92-foot-long solar telescope would be housed in an observatory that would be, depending on whom one asks, 11 or 14 stories high. The proposed project would be the world’s largest optical solar telescope, with a 13-foot-diameter main mirror that would help provide the sharpest views ever of the sun.

    The idea behind the telescope, according to the supplemental draft EIS, is to study solar magnetic activities, the Earth’s climate and space weather – mainly sunspots and the mass ejections of radiation they often create when the
    spots develop in pairs.

    The plasma radiation mass ejections, which are related to solar flares, have been known to knock out power
    grids and disable satellites. They could also sicken or kill astronauts or airline passengers unexpectedly caught in their path, Maberry said.

    Scientists hope to use the telescope to help understand and predict the sun’s behavior, he said.

    The solar telescope would be built on 0.86 acres at Pu’u Kolekole, within sight of Haleakala’s summit. In a two-year study, 70 possible sites worldwide were considered for the solar telescope observatory.

    “This is not a pork project,” Maberry said. “It is a highly peer-reviewed telescope and was identified as the top priority for the National Science Foundation.”

    But since its inception, the proposed Advanced Technology Solar Telescope has raised the ire of many Native
    Hawaiians and their supporters.

    The project is just another eyesore on the top of Haleakala, they said. Just digging into the lava rock, which is believed by many Native Hawaiians to be the bones of the volcano goddess Pele, is sacrilegious.

    Telescope opponents, such as Maxwell, add that the fact that the 48-year-old Science City is located on ceded lands (former Hawaiian monarchy property taken over by the United States upon annexation and turned over to the state upon statehood) is yet another insult.

    The Advanced Technology Solar Telescope would join the following observatories in the Science City complex, all of which are off-limits to the general public:

    *
    U.S. Air Force Maui Space Surveillance Complex and the AEOS telescope, which at 3.67 meters is the largest in the Department of Defense catalog, the Maui Space Surveillance System and the U.S. Air Force Space Command’s GEODDS telescope.

    * Faulkes Telescope, which is owned by Las Combres Observatories, a private British education and outreach organization.

    *
    UH’s Pan-STARS, which boasts the world’s largest digital camera at 1.44 giga-pixels, as well as Mees Solar, Solar-C Scatter-Free, Air Glow, Baker Nunn, Zodiacal Light and TLRS 4 observatories.

    The observatories’ missions vary from studying the size of the universe, to trying to predict whether Earth will run into the path of asteroids or comets, to tracking satellites and space junk.

    Last week, Maxwell stood in Pukalani and dismissively waved a hand toward the top of Haleakala, which was literally clouded from view, and declared that although he is a cultural consultant to Science City, he opposes its very existence.

    Do they really need to construct yet another bright white and too-tall telescope, Maxwell asked. Why not build it
    shorter and darker, he asked.

    “There’s a cumulative effect,” he said. “The more you put up there, the more it washes out the sacred nature of the place.”

    Maberry said that the height is required to meet the telescope’s needs, and the light color is necessary for a day-time telescope so it doesn’t attract heat, which distorts the image and disrupts targeting systems.

    “Everyone understands this is not just a special place for Hawaiians,” Maxwell said. “This is where our alii (royalty) were buried, and where the gods and the spirits of our ancestors live.”

    Maberry said specialists have studied Science City’s archaeology extensively and found no burials in the area. The new solar telescope would also be the last project in the undeveloped portion of Science City.

    “We’re already there,” Maberry said. “And we’re being as respectful as we possibly can to the host culture and their concerns.”

    Experts such as Maxwell are hired to educate Science City workers so they know they are working in a sacred place, like a church, Maberry said. Employees must follow codes of conduct that include no smoking or urinating outdoors.

    Haleakala, or the “House of the Sun,” rests firmly in Hawaiian lore as the place where the demigod Maui roped the
    sun in order to slow its pace across the sky. Supporters have said the history makes it a fitting place for solar astronomical exploration.

    However, opponents of the telescope have organized their own broad-based coalition, called Kilakila O Haleakala. The nonprofit created solely to fight the telescope is led by Maui Community College Hawaiian language instructor Kiope Raymond and award-winning Native Hawaiian cultural practitioner Ed Lindsey.

    “The construction of a 14-story solar observatory on the sacred summit of Haleakala cannot be mitigated by
    implying that since our ancestors were farmers, fishermen, healers, artists and yes, astronomers, then building the observatory is consistent with Native Hawaiian tradition and spirituality,” Raymond said.

    The argument that the telescope is appropriate because Hawaiians revered astronomy is a fallacy, he said.

    Maxwell asked the National Science Foundation instead to build a planetarium for Native Hawaiian students and “help make them into scientists.” But he said he hasn’t heard back from the agency.

    So, Maxwell and others said they’ll be looking forward to upcoming public hearings to once again make their arguments.

    For more information both for and against the telescope, go on the Web to atst.nso.edu and karenchun.com/storedsites/kilakilahaleakala.org.

    * Chris Hamilton can be reached at chamilton@mauinews.com.

    PROPOSED ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY SOLAR TELESCOPE

    Public comments on the proposed Advanced Technology Solar Telescope (ATST) atop Haleakala must be received or postmarked by June 22.

    Copies of the supplemental draft environmental impact statement for the telescope project can be found at all Maui public libraries and on the Internet at atst.nso.edu/.

    Public comments will be heard:

    * June 3, from 5 to 8 p.m. at the Cameron Center in Wailuku.

    * June 4, from 7 to 10 p.m. at the Mayor Hannibal Tavares Community Center in Pukalani.

    Original comments should be mailed to Craig Foltz, ATST program manager;
    National Science Foundation, Division of Astronomical Sciences; 4201
    Wilson Blvd., Room 1045; Arlington, Va. 22230.

    Other ways to reach Foltz include: telephone, (703) 292-4909; fax, (703) 292-9034; and e-mail, cfoltz@nsf.gov.

    Copies of comments also should be sent to:

    *
    The state Department of Health, Office of Environmental Quality
    Control, Ref. ATST; 235 S. Beretania St., Room 702; Honolulu 96813.
    Fax: (808) 586-4186.

    * Mike Maberry, associate director;
    University of Hawaii Institute for Astronomy; 34 Ohia Ku St., Pukalani
    96768. Fax: (808) 573-9557.

    * Charlie Fein, KC Environmental Inc.; P.O. Box 1208, Makawao 96768. Fax: (808) 573-7837; e-mail: charlie@kcenv.com.

    Consultation meetings to solicit public input under the National Historic Preservation Act will be held on Maui by the National Science Foundation and Haleakala National Park.

    The schedule of meetings is:

    * June 8, 1 to 4 p.m. at the Kula Community Center.

    * June 9, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. at the Haiku Community Center.

    * June 10, 3 to 6 p.m. at Maui Community College’s Pilina Building Multipurpose Room.

  • News

    Articles, Papers & News

    May 2009 newsletter from National Park Service/ Haleakala National Park
    (see page 2 for the information on NEPA meetings on June 3 and 4 and for contact information to send their comments on the Draft Envioronmental Impact Statement. In addition, page 3 is a really good summary of what the 106 meetings are about and also information on the 106 meetings June 8, 9 and 10. )

    Haleakala Getting Crowded  backup

    Haleakala Solar Telescope a Desecration

    Haleakalā – The Sacred House of the Sun (Comments on DEIS)

    Professor (Emeritus) Dick Mayer (Comments on DEIS)

    University of Hawai`i Environmental Center (Comments on DEIS)

    Ed Lindsey’s Letter (Comments on DEIS)

    Office of Hawaiian Affairs (Comments on DEIS)

    Friends of Haleakalā Position Statement

    Hawaiians continue to protest solar telescope  (Maui News)

    Haleakala National Park Opposes Solar Telescope (Maui News)

    Seeker of knowledge suggests moving solar telescope

    Friends of national park oppose site of solar telescope

    UH Press Release Describing Telescope

  • Haleakala Solar Telescope Desecration

    Maui News May 21, 2009

    Emerson Earl considers small roadside shrines “trash” (Letters, April 14) but declaims that a 20 story concrete eyesore on top of Haleakala is “appropriate” (Letters, May 17). He goes on to spout a lot of grandiose but meaningless words about the proposed telescope.

    I don’t have a strong opinion on the telescope. But then, I am not Hawaiian. I listen to Hawaiian friends and relatives when they tell me that this is a desecration and culturally inappropriate. Only a very ungracious guest of Maui would ignore their words and trample our hosts’ sacred place.

    I hope that proponents of the solar telescope can find a little ha’aha’a and open their eyes to “miracles” a lot more solid and “appropriate” to Maui than a two-edged sword of science.

    I truly feel sorry for anyone who exists in a ha’ole bubble – a sort of piece of the Mainland on Maui – that causes them to remain oblivious to the entire dimension of Hawaiian culture.

    Respect the culture. Wake up and realize that there is a culture on the island that is different from yours.

    Karen Chun
    Paia

  • Panelists Discuss the Clash of Cultures and Land Ownership on Hawaii’s Sacred Peaks

    ‘The law of Aloha is in the land.’ Kealoha Pisciotta

    Respect for Kanaka Maoli Spiritual Practices

    Panelists explained that from a kanaka maoli perspective, the summit of Haleakala is considered ‘wao akua,’or the realm of the gods. The very lands of Haleakala are seen by many as the kinolau (physical manifestation) of the sacred goddess Pele, a place that should be regarded as a temple.

    Kiope Raymond and Kealoha Pisciotta
    Sierra Club Maui, MCC Hawaiian Studies Program, and Kilakila o Haleakala sponsored a May 17th panel discussion on a new 14 story tall telescope proposed for the summit of Haleakala. Pictured above,are panelists Kiope Raymond, Hawaiian Studies Department head at MCCand President of Kilakila o Haleakala and Kealoha Pisciotta, president of Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, a group on Hawaii Island that led an alliance (including Sierra Club) who successfully challenged the state for failing to follow its own management plan and deal with the impacts of expanding the telescope complex on the summit Mauna Kea.

    Kanaka maoli come to such places to worship and feel close to their ancestors.

    Psciotta, who had worked at a telescope facility on Mauna Kea for many years, expressed respect for the scientists who work on the mountain, but not for the treatment of the land. She referred to the many pollutants (such as mercury and other waste products ) that came with the use and maintenance of the telescope facilities and the fact that their impacts on groundwater and native flora and fauna were not adequately considered by the state.

    KilaKila board members are concerned that the summit of Haleakala has no comprehensive management plan. No one seems to be discussing the huge amount of energy the proposed 14-storyhigh ‘solar’ telescope would be consuming on Maui to maintain ideal temperatures in its huge footprint. All the panelists referred to the need to leave the landforms unaltered on the mountain peaks because they have connections to other landforms which are all part of the kanaka maoli spiritual tradition.

    It is with great sadness that we morn the passing of
    Ed Lindsey who worked hard to preserve Haleakalā

    Ed Lindsey & Debbie Ward
    Panelists Ed Lindsey,president of Maui Cultural Lands and Debbie Ward, who worked closely on the Mauna Kea telescope challenge campaign as a representative of the Sierra Club’s Moku Loa (Big Island) group.  Not pictured are the fifth panelist, Kaleikoa Kaeo, Hawaiian studies professor at MCC and panel moderator Rich Lucas. Representatives of the UH Institute of Astronomy and others supporting the telescope project were invited to be panelists, but they declined to participate at this time.

    Land Ownership:

    The telescopes of Haleakala’s ‘Science City'(more properly described as the Ahupua’a of Papa’anui in the district,or moku of Honua’ula) sit on ceded land. These are lands that belong to the Hawaiian Kingdom and were ‘ceded’ to the U.S. government with the 1898 annexation. Most of the 1.8 million acres of’ ceded’ lands became ‘state lands’ when upon Hawaii statehood in 1959. A recent Hawaii Supreme Court ruling decreed that the state had no authority to enter into agreements about the ceded lands with other parties until the land claims of kanaka maoli were settled. The state is appealing this decision.

    A New Vision:

    Panelists, all of whom opposed the construction of further buildings on Hawaiian mountain peaks, were united in one vision. The state of Hawaii needed to have a shift in perspective regarding the island’s land. Ceded lands need to be managed by kanaka maoli. Mountain peaks like Haleakala and Mauna Kea need to be respected as part of the spiritual heritage of all of Hawaii’s people, not as a real estate commodity to be leased by state agencies for a dollar a year to military and research facilities whose activities can impact landforms native creatures and the groundwater sources.

    ‘Aloha is the guiding principle of our life here in Hawaii,’ explained Pisciotta ‘and the law of Aloha is in the land.’

  • Sierra Club Comments

    Haleakalā
    The Sacred House of the Sun

     

    Hawaiian Protocol for Sacred Places
    E Ui No Ka ‘Ae
    Ask Permission,
    E Mahalo Aku
    Give Thanks,
    E Komo Me Ka Hōano
    Enter With Reverence,
    I ka hele aku, e ho’oma’amau I ka wahi!
    When you leave, return it as you found it!

    The summit of Haleakalā represents many things to the indigenous people of Hawai’i.   The ancient spiritual use of Haleakalā was for meditation and receiving spiritual wisdom by na Kāhuna Po’o (the lead priests).   It is said to be a place where the tones of ancient prayer are balanced within the vortex of energy for spiritual manifestations.   In ancient times, only the Kāhuna and their haumana (students) lived at Haleakalā for initiation rites and practices.   All who visit Haleakalā should strive to become sensitized to the subtleties of nature and the culture of this sacred place.  Considering the aggregated eons of history at Haleakalā, this summit demands respect.   It is a place of prayer; it is Ala hea ka la – the path to calling the sun.
    When Pele, the goddess of fire, first visited Haleakalā, she dug a deep pit and made sixteen pu’u (hills, cinder cones).   These pu’u form a sacred alignment from the summit of Haleakalā, to the tip of Haneo’o and continues for about 30 miles into the ocean.   Along this path, on the eastern side of Haleakalā, there were over 300 heiau (temples), the highest concentration in the Hawaiian archipelago.    The ancient Hawaiians knew these things about Haleakalā and kept its secrets for those coming after to love, protect and preserve.  Those that ventured there in the days of old did so with care and reverence, to worship, and to observe the heavens (as well as for navigation).
    To take any action, other than NO ACTION, would be a trespass on one of the most sacred and revered sites on Earth.   When Jay April’s wonderful film Haleakalā: A Sense of Place was shown at the Maui Arts and Cultural Center, Kahu Uncle Charlie Maxwell was asked the question if he thought it was appropriate to make a jump from how ancient Hawaiians observed and used the stars to how UH IfA and the Air Force propose to use the sacred summit with defense projects such as Pan-STARRS.  He responded by saying he didn’t know, “…but they would have to follow all the rules that were set forth to follow cultural protocol and cultural respect of the land before anything is built.”  He then added” Oh, and one more I forgot:  That if they are going to build anything, they got to tear something down and put it in its place.”
    None of the five buildings at the top of this inimitable summit have been taken down yet, but   at the last informational community meeting at Pukalani in 2006, one of the members of the ATST team informed the public that each facility has an estimated service life.   He further stated that at the conclusion of its useful service, the facility should be dismantled and the site returned to its natural state.   He added that two facilities on the mainland would be dismantled when the ATST project was put up.     Therefore, all references in the DEIS suggesting that this project has a less significant impact on the sacredness of Haleakalā, because previous projects have already been constructed near the site (inferring that the damage has already been done so one more won’t really make that much difference) should be rethought.   If all future construction is stopped immediately and no further action of any type is taken, then at some designated point of time in the foreseeable future Haleakalā will be returned to its natural state.   Each additional project subjects this irreplaceable sacred site to more desecration.   At what point will it be irretrievably altered?   Certainly it is time to stop and repair the damage.  Haleakalā undoubtedly deserves that much respect, and much much more.   You might listen to the heartfelt song Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā (Majestic Haleakalā), if you want to get a feel for the deep respect this wonderful mountain deserves.
    As noted in the DEIS, the construction of the 14 story structure is viewed by Native Hawaiians to be a cultural desecration of a sacred site.   It will have a significant impact on the view shed in an adverse manner and will irreversibly interfere with the United States Constitutionally protected spiritual practices of  the indigenous people of Hawaii.  For the above reasons alone, a decision of no action should be an easy and correct conclusion.
    If you want other specific reasons, they are present as well.    We are assuming for purposes of this comment, that all community comments presented at community meetings during the discussion periods throughout Maui Nui will be incorporated into the Final EIS.   We were told when the members of the community presented their oral testimony that it would be transcribed and submitted to NSF to be included in the Final EIS, so we will not duplicate the comments presented at those meetings herein and the DEIS should be corrected accordingly.

    Mitigation of Cultural Resources:  In Kahu Charles Kauluwehi Maxwell Sr.’s  Final Report entitled E Malama Mau ka La’a, there appears to be an initial assumption that this project will be constructed irrespective of the objections to the building of the ATST on Haleakalā.   For purposes of a cultural resources and traditional practices evaluation, the preparer should have considered all possible options, including the option of “no action”, which does not seem to be the case.
    On page 62 of his report, Kahu Maxwell acknowledges that “any building or structure built on this site is an intrusion on the sacredness and spirituality of this mountain revered by the Hawaiian people past and present,” and then goes on to conclude that a balance between building on the site and the cultural practices of the Hawaiian people must be reached.   There does not appear to be a logical correlation between these two statements, and he does not explain why he can come to the conclusion that a balance between digging and desecration is what should be achieved.   In fact, an assessment with an open mind to “no action” should have drawn a completely different conclusion.   This report is incomplete and should be re-evaluated with the “no action” alternative considered.
    Additionally, there is no legal or rational nexus between the cause and effect listed in his report.   He starts with the premise that “any building or structure built on this site is an intrusion on the sacredness and spirituality of this mountain revered by the Hawaiian people past and present,” and then apparently concludes that this premise can be adequately mitigated by certain actions he suggests, including the use of cultural protocol before, during and after construction.   Unfortunately, this proposed mitigation will not reverse, stop or even diminish the desecration.   It might make some feel better about it, but the desecration will remain.   The report seems to imply that the proposed violation would be lessened by building with cultural sensitivity.   In fact, any construction on the summit is absolute desecration of sacred ground.  Greater sensitivity on the part of the construction workers is not an appropriate response to desecrating sacred ground.   As noted in the DEIS, any foundation excavation on the mountaintop would be a wound to a highly sacred place.    The only way to stop the desecration is to prohibit it from happening in the first place. This possibility is blatantly ignored in the present report.
    First Amendment religious rights are allowed to be absolute just because of their nature.   They are not limited to shades of gray.   This is one of those absolutes.   “No action” should be indicated.
    Interestingly, the National Science Foundation found that the summit constitutes a “traditional cultural property”, a term used by the National Register of Historic Places to identify properties eligible for inclusion in the National Register because of their association with the cultural practices or beliefs of a “living community.”   This view is shared by the State Historic Preservation Division at the DLNR.   (Honolulu Advertiser October 12, 2006)    When a property is placed within the Historic Registry, it is protected from such desecration as would occur on this site should the project go forward.   Haleakalā should be offered the same protection as any other “traditional cultural property” and, when that standard is applied herein, no action should be taken.
    In addition, the report never considered any similar projects that were proposed on sacred or cultural sites.   In order to prepare a proper mitigation analysis on the sites at Haleakalā, other sacred sites with similar projects actually built upon them need to be considered, including whether the proposed mitigation actually worked or not.   In addition, similar sacred sites that were considered, but the projects were not completed because the cultural resources could not be adequately protected or mitigated, should be discussed as well.    Such comparisons are necessary to effectively present an adequate mitigation analysis.   Otherwise, this could be deemed to be speculative in nature.
    The cultural resources analysis should be reconsidered.   The actual “least impact as possible” referred to in the report should not be limited to the mitigation matters suggested.   The least impact as possible should be not to construct the ATST on Haleakalā.    For once, put the needs of the Hawaiian people to the forefront.   That would be pono.

    View Planes:  
                The summit of Haleakalā is one of the most beautiful vistas on Hawaii   It is almost comical to imply that a 14 story telescope on the summit of this magnificent mountain will not dominate or displace a significant fraction of that vista.   Trying to focus people on the fact that you have the rest of the mountain to look at is not relevant to the issue.   When you look at Haleakalā, where do your eyes focus?   Inevitably, they take you to the summit.   The summit is the optimal view plane, and that is where this facility will be located.   The fact that it is less obtrusive from different parts of the island is not the point.   If it is obtrusive to kama’aina or tourists from any where on the island,  that is sufficient reason to decide that it should not be built.   Over 1,000,000 tourists go to the summit of Haleakalā National Park every year.   They rise at 2 in the morning and drive to the Ranger Station overlooking the crater to view the sunrise over the crater.    In the DEIS, it was noted that a big consideration at the La Palma site (second over-all choice) was the impact the telescope might have on the view from a specific peak called the Cumbrecita.   This view is so important to the visitors of that area that the government enacted laws and the local courts handed down decisions that protected that special view plane.   The telescope could not have been built there if it interfered with that particular view plane. Shouldn’t the same consideration be given to Haleakalā, which is sacred as well as beautiful?  (The findings in the DEIS are that there were no known archaeological or culturally important features in the area that would be impacted by construction of ATST at La Palma.  Another reason it should be constructed at La Palma, not Haleakalā).
    The DEIS makes the statement that the construction of the ATST would have a less than significant impact on the view plane.   (pg ES-22).   One of the factors the report relied upon in forming this conclusion, apparently, is their bold assertion that the14 story starkly high white telescope on the summit of Haleakalā is considered by some to be not even noticeable and/or even beautiful.   Of interest, we could not find one person who heard anyone testify that they thought the structure would be a beautiful addition to the vista.   To try to imply that a majority or even a substantial minority of Hawaiians or visitors to the Island of Maui would find such a structure beautiful is simply misdirection.   View planes can be subjective, but in coming to the conclusion of “less than significant impact”, the report should give greater consideration to the opinions of the large majority of individuals viewing this magnificent vista.   The overwhelming majority opinion of those giving testimony regarding view planes is that it would interfere with their view plane and that was not acceptable.   To state categorically that it is just a matter of opinion implies that it’s closer to 50/50 than what it probably is —  at minimum 95/5.  To state “we cannot describe that impact as an irrevocable loss of visual resources” is laughable.  The view will be irrevocably lost.   Hawaiian spiritual practitioners facing the summit of Haleakalā each morning will be irretrievably injured by this injustice and their indigenous religious rights will be unjustly damaged.     This telescope can be built elsewhere, and that is what should happen.

    Land Use/Archaeological:
    The County of Maui prohibits any building over the height of 12 stories.  The ATST project apparently believes that it should be exempt from this law, because it is being built on ceded lands controlled by the University of Hawaii, a State entity.   At the same time, the DEIS implies that they are in compliance with all local and state land use laws and community plans.   The DEIS should state that if the project is not exempt, it would violate numerous county and local land use ordinances and guidelines.
    This project could not be built in downtown Kahului, and it should not be able to be built on the top of Haleakalā.   The County of Maui enacted the 12 story limit for many important reasons, including under its police powers, and these same reasons should apply to this facility as well, especially in light of the recent seismic events around the Islands.
    In Section 1.8, the DEIS implies that the proposed action conforms to the Upcountry community plans, and this is not so.   For example, the Makawao/Pukaluna/Kula Community Plan (enacted in 1996) prohibits buildings over 35 feet tall.  This facility would not fit within any of the exceptions therein and, therefore, is not in compliance.
    The impact on the road from the Rangers Station to the summit is not addressed in the DEIS.  Who will be doing the repairs on this road and what other impacts are there?
    The DEIS asserts that there is no mitigation anticipated or planned for archaeological resources.   What about the possible cave in the area named Anamakauahi?   Surely at such an important cultural, historical site there are other archaeological concerns as well that have not been addressed.
    There is none or inadequate reference to the Hawaiian Mahele and land titles.   The issue of ceded lands in Hawaii has not been resolved and continues to be raised in litigation in state and federal courts, and it is irresponsible not to address this issue.   The lands could also be subject to reparation and/or rent fees due and owing to the Kingdom of Hawaii, but this is not addressed anywhere in the DEIS.   Notwithstanding the issue regarding whether Gov. Quinn actually had the right to give away these ceded lands, since neither he nor the State of Hawaii owned the lands, there is also an issue regarding the appropriate purpose of ceded lands .   As noted by the Office of Hawaiian Affairs in the comment in October 2005, these Public Trust lands may be used for educational purposes and for the betterment of Hawaiians.   The State has a Constitutional responsibility to “conserve and protect Hawaii’s natural beauty and all natural resources, including land, water, air, minerals and energy sources…All public natural resources are held in trust by the State for the benefit of the people.”  (Hawai’i State Constitution, Art. XI, Section 1). The state also has a Constitutional responsibility to “protect all rights, customarily and traditionally exercised for subsistence, cultural and religious purposes” possessed by Hawaiians.  (Hawai’i State Constitution, Art.. XII, Section 2)  These considerations, as required by the State Constitution, must be given precedent over scientific needs of the world at large, especially since the scientific needs can be met elsewhere.

    Biological Resources:
    It is inconceivable that a finding of less than significant could be anticipated in an area that abounds with unique Hawaiian plants and animals.  As noted by Art Medeiros, one of the most knowledgeable experts on this particular topic “[t]he mark this monolith would make on Maui would be significant and irrevocable….The quest for knowledge is beautiful, but its demands must be weighed against the other sacred and beautiful things of the limited area of Maui, aspects of our Hawaiian culture, the lives of unique native plants and animals and the grace of the clean lines of Haleakalā’s ethereal high Pacific mountain viewscapes.”
    The effect on these resources could be quite significant.   Construction activity could cause death to the ‘ua’u; human proximity could cause them to abandon their burrows; construction would (not could) destroy hundreds of native plants; Nene would be affected by human proximity and also by potential pesticides and other contaminants, including but not limited to plastics and lead which they could ingest.  The assumption in the DEIS that the botanical resources would not be permanently affected should clearly be re-examined.
    We will not address this subject in depth, since it will be covered in detail in comments by more knowledgeable Native Hawaiian practitioners, but it is noteworthy that although there are listed endangered species at the sites on Haleakalā, there are no listed endangered species at the alternative site at La Palma.   On the issues that could result in irreparable harm (such as vegetation and habitat, cultural resources, view planes, etc),  the DEIS appears to take the position that these can be mitigated easily enough.   On the other hand, the dust issue at La Palma appears to be based in part on inconvenience, addressing monetary concerns and the time it would take to rectify the problem.   Clearly some of the partners planning to use the facilities (such as the Department of Defense and Homeland Security) have enough funds to spend whatever money is necessary to take care of that issue and hire as many personnel as are needed, with no irreparable damage done to Haleakalā and its unique habitats.

    Economic Concerns: 
    The DEIS asserts that the ATST will bring economic gain to the County of Maui and State of Hawaii.   What is not addressed are the negative impacts to Maui and state economies.   As noted by the Association of Hawaiian Civic Clubs in its written comments, the construction of a 14 story telescope would destroy the pristine landscape of Haleakalā, which is a sacred cultural site, the unblemished beauty of which has been recorded for centuries in Hawaiian legends, chants and songs.   They further note that Native Hawaiians revere this site as a place of great mana, and that it is one of the most popular tourist destinations on Maui.    We agree with this esteemed Association and the Hawai’i Tourism Authority that well over half of Maui residents have listed “loss of Nature and open space” as a big problem on Maui.
    Tourism is the economic life blood of Maui.  Aside from government jobs, the tourist industry accounts for more than 50% of the total personal income of Maui residents, more than construction, real estate, manufacturing, finance, and retail trade combined.  (DEIS 3-46, Table 3-8)    Maui has been designated the number one tourist designation island in the world.   It enjoys that distinction, in large part, due to its natural beauty and unspoiled vistas.   The summit of Haleakalā is the single most visited site on the island.   It does not require a leap of faith to conclude that any diminishment of Haleakalā is likely to have significant, adverse economic impact on the island and its people.  This aspect of the proposed project is not adequately addressed in the DEIS.   This type of impact was addressed in your comments about La Palma regarding the effect of the view plane on tourists there, but it is noticeably absent in your evaluation of Haleakalā.
    Hawaii is a unique and special place in the world.  The Hawaii Economic Momentum Commission, appointed by the governor, issued a final report in December, 2005.  In that report, the Commission concluded that “the Hawaiian culture, including its value systems . . .  not only defines Hawaii, but is the only thing that distinguishes our islands from every other sea, sand and sun resort” in the world.  Trying to educate and familiarize visitors of the significance and beauty of the Hawaiian culture, while desecrating one of the most sacred of Hawaiian sites, is an incongruity that cannot be explained away with slick marketing brochures.  We cannot embrace the Hawaiian culture without first respecting it.

    General Considerations:
    Haleakalā is the Sacred House of the Sun.   The spiritual First Amendment rights of the Native Hawaiian people should trump any dust or sky brightness issues.   Clearly this telescope can be built elsewhere.   Over 70 sites were considered, and it is inconceivable that La Palma and Big Bear Lake could get to the top 3 sites if they were not viable.   Another possibility is that the telescope could be built in space, which was not even mentioned in the DEIS, although it is a clear alternative.  The fact that the Haleakalā sites may possibly have a few advantages in some areas should not be the deciding factor.   The cultural and religious issues at Haleakalā should be given the greatest consideration.   Not only are these rights protected by the United States and Hawaii Constitutions, but, more importantly, it is the righteous and correct decision to make under the circumstances.
    Another issue not adequately address is the clean up and disposal of the project when it is no longer necessary.   Certainly, the current building(s) that have been abandoned (such as the former radio telescope site known as Reber Circle which goes back to the1950’s – and which interestingly enough was abandoned because it did not work) was not cleared out and the land was not returned to its natural habitat even though the facility was abandoned over half a century ago.  In fact, it has now been there so long it has historical significance.   There have also been voiced concerns from local residents who lived here during the first construction phases at Kolekole that trash was not handled responsibly at that time.
    It is interesting to review the written comments contained in the DEIS.   The ones supporting the project are 99%  simply signatures on the exact same form letter with no personal comments or reasons for support.   On the other hand, many of the comments opposing the telescope are written from the heart and display a great deal of emotion.  A few examples of these:   “There are 70 other possible sites for this telescope…there is only one sacred Haleakalā…there can be no compromise…this site is sacred to the Native people of Hawaii—it must be preserved.”  “The “house of the Sun” is holy.   Would you build a 16 story telescope on the top of Notre Dame?  Some places on our precious planet must be singled out…Haleakalā is one of these places.   Please do not allow it to be dishonored.”   Those opposing this project speak out because they respect and honor Haleakalā – desecration is not inevitable and the project should be built elsewhere.   Those supporting the project are speaking about the need for scientific data – not scientific data limited to Haleakalā.   This data can be gathered on grounds that are not sacred.   This is an extremely important point.   The sacred summit of Haleakalā is limited to this particular site – the data is not.
    As noted above, the references throughout that the “grounds are already disturbed by development” should be played down as well, because those facilities will apparently be taken down at the end of their service life.  If we keep building on this site, these significant impacts will never go away.   Allow this sacred ground to be returned to its natural state as quickly as possible, and stop further desecration now.   The prior damage can hopefully be remedied; if it continues it cannot.   You did not consider Machu Picchu or Mt. Zion as plausible sites for this facility, and rightly so.   Haleakalā is just as sacred.   Please act accordingly.

    Mahalo for your consideration.

    Maui Group Sierra Club

     

    By Kathleen S. McDuff, Vice Chairman
     

    The Hawaiians observed and used the stars to navigate their way safely throughout Oceania.   Hokule’a, Hawai’i’s zenith star, Hokupa’a (the North Star) and the peaks of Mauna Kea and Haleakala were used to navigate their way safely into the ‘Alenuihaha and ‘Alalakeiki channels.    The Kahuna Kilokilo (a priest who would watch the skies for omens) studied the sky from the summit of Haleakala.

    The subject lands are Section 5(b) lands of the Hawaii Admission Act (Act of March 18, 1959, Pub. L. 86-3, 73 Stat.4). j  As such these are ceded lands, and per § 5(b) and the income derived therefrom, “shall be managed and disposed of for one or more” of the five listed purposes.   The Act lists the five purposes as:  for the support of the public schools and other public educational institutions, for the betterment of the conditions of native Hawaiians,…for the development of farm and home ownership on as widespread a basis as possible, for the making of public improvements, and for the provision of lands for public trust.

     

  • Maui Cultural Lands Testimony

    Maui Cultural Lands, Inc.
    1087-A Pookela Road
    Makawao, Hi 96568

    It is with great concern that many of us Kanaka Maoli are compelled to give testimony against a project that is so destructive to the well being of the Hawaiian culture and its sacred sites. The building of the solar telescope needs to be addressed at four levels: legal, physical, political, and cultural.

    Through executive order by the late Governor Quinn, the University of Hawaii was given control to develop a science city on our sacred mountain sites. However, your project proposal goes counter to the many federal, state and county laws:

    • Hawaiian Admissions Act, Public law 8603, 73 stat. 4(f) The betterment of the conditions of Native Hawaiians.
    • Hawaii State Constitution, Art. XI sect. 1, protect Natural cultural and Religious resources.
    • US Constitution First Amendment Religious Freedom. Native Hawaiian Religious Practitioners’ rights will be violated.
    • Federal Law, Endangered species and Habitat Act.
    • EPA hazardous materials act
    • County ordinances concerning community plans.
    • Failure for the University of Hawaii to develop a comprehensive use plan where the public is able to give input.

    While this may just be the beginning, other laws and legal problems may surface as more people become aware of what is happening on Haleakalā. To ignore or to try mitigation proposals of these laws of the land weakens the fabric of those values we hold close to our state and national foundations.

    The physical and environmental make up of Haleakalā is among the most unique in the world. Endangered and threatened endemic plants, insects, animals, and habitat cannot be successfully mitigated once excavations of many pylons going down into the bowels of this dormant volcano 20-40 feet deep. Excavations now and in the past have always encouraged invasive species to take hold. To proceed with your project would contribute to the destruction of our native ecosystems that have already started at the base and the solar telescope would destroy our natural treasures form the summit.

    The National Historic and Preservation Act, while a legal requirement, falls more into the politics of getting away with your project needs instead of doing what the community demands to be the correct path. In spite of Sect. 106, mitigate, minimize or avoidance, all the testimony against a project given by the host culture may be ignored. Other politically motivated reasons to support this telescope may be unethical because of future contractual agreements. One hundred seventy five million dollars worth of contracts will attract many “friends” and supporters. The love of money supersedes ethical behavior.

    Many indigenous cultures throughout the world recognize many works of nature as sacred. When a culture depends on these natural wonders of their environment for survival and reverence communications to a power higher than themselves, all care must be given to this practice. Haleakalā is noted throughout Polynesia as one of a most sacred area. There are stories, legends, events, but most importantly, prayers by generations of Kahunas. As many visitors can testify there is a life force within these rocks that have influenced their lives. For the National Science Foundation, and scientists to belittle this belief, they unknowingly contribute to the genocidal practice of wiping out the people of Aloha.

    In conclusion, do NOT minimize the host culture of these islands, to do so would be unworthy for you to study the sun.

    Respectfully submitted,

    Edwin R.N. Lindsey Jr.
    President, Maui Cultural Lands, Inc.
    Board Member, Kila Kila O Haleakalā