Author: fueji

  • At least 8 arrested as protectors block telescope convoy

    Early on the morning of Thursday, August 20, 2015, about 150 people gathered at the Central Maui Baseyard, where trucks carrying parts for the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope were expected to leave for the summit. Protectors marched, chanted and offered lei to slow the convoy, with a second gathering upcountry. Organizers said at least eight people were arrested.

    Read the full report from Hawaii News Now: At least 8 protesters arrested at summit of Haleakalā (August 20, 2015).

  • Status of litigation as of August 2015

    Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā, represented by the Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation, has filed four lawsuits challenging the construction of the massive advanced technology solar telescope (ATST) – now called the DKIST – project that includes a 142.7 foot tall building and a wastewater treatment plant on the summit of Haleakalā. We have won two of them, and are awaiting decisions from the Hawai`i Supreme Court as to the other two.

    I. The Four Cases

    In December 2010, the board of land and natural resources (BLNR) voted to grant a conservation district use permit for the ATST project without first holding a required contested case hearing, which Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā had requested. Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā appealed that decision. The Hawai`i Supreme Court ruled that the Board should not have voted without giving Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā the opportunity to present evidence and cross-examine the University’s witnesses See Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā v. Bd. of Land & Natural Res., 131 Hawai’i 193, 317 P.3d 27 (2013). In February 2014 that permit was voided.

    In December 2010, the BLNR also approved a management plan for the summit of Haleakalā. Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā sued because the University failed to prepare an environmental impact statement for the management plan. The University had admitted that the ATST project, which was part of the management plan, would have “major, adverse, short- and long-term, direct impacts on the traditional cultural resources.” The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in that case in December 2014. A decision should be issued within the next couple of months.

    After voting to grant the December 2010 permit, the BLNR then held an after-the-fact permit to rubberstamp its approval. BLNR appointed a hearing officer.

    In 2012, Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā learned that the University had been applying political pressure on the hearing officer. Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā requested public documents from the University through the state’s freedom of information act, HRS chapter 92F. The University illegally withheld the documents. Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā sued – and won. Circuit court judge Rhonda Nishimura ordered the University to hand over the documents. Internal documents revealed that the Governor Abercrombie’s office and U.S. Senator Inouye’s office exerted political pressure on the BLNR Chair to approve the ATST project.

    Senator Inouye’s Chief of Staff, Jennifer Sabas, acting on behalf of the University, along with the governor’s chief of staff met behind closed doors with the chair of the BLNR “to discuss the telescope, hearings officer and funding issue” – during the course of the after-the-fact hearing.

    Soon after that – and while the contested case hearing was still on-going – the BLNR allowed some construction activities authorized by the December 2010 permit to start.

    In November 2012, BLNR once again granted a conservation district use permit for the ATST project. Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā appealed again. The Hawai`i Supreme Court heard oral arguments in April. A decision is expected by the end of the year.

    II. Basic Facts

    1. The Haleakalā Summit is Culturally Significant and Rich in Natural Beauty.

    The summit area of Haleakalā is considered a significant traditional cultural site. The summit area is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. According to the University, “The large number of remnant archaeological sites indicates that the area was used and therefore held significance during traditional times.” A number of traditional cultural practices are conducted in the Haleakalā summit area.

    The summit of Haleakala is also a site of spectacular natural beauty. The telescope is being built within a few hundred yards of the Haleakalā National Park. The purpose of Haleakalā National Park includes preserving the area’s scenic character and cultural resource values.

    B. The Applicant Sought BLNR Approval to Construct at the Summit.

    The ATST project includes: the telescope; a support and operations building adjacent to the observatory; a utilities building; a parking lot; a wastewater treatment plant; a new electrical transformer; three ice storage tanks; and a diesel generator. The solar telescope would be encased within a facility that would stand 142.7 feet tall and stretch 84 feet in diameter. The ATST telescope building would exceed the height of existing facilities in the area by about fifty feet. The 76.3 foot high support and operations building next to the ATST would contain: a large docking bay, a 20-ton crane, equipment storage, laboratories, a large-scale platform lift, a helium compressor, a vacuum pump and liquid nitrogen tanks. The support and operations building itself would be bigger than some other structures in the area. The utility building for the ATST project would contain a 300 KVA generator, an 80-ton chiller, a 15-ton chiller, a 10-ton heat pump condenser unit, two ventilation fans, an air compressor, a vacuum pump and three uninterruptible power supply units. The entire ATST project would occupy a footprint of .74 acres. The ATST project would also require the handling and storage of hazardous materials including: hydrochloric acid, potassium hydroxide, nitric acid, stripping/ cleaning effluent, aluminum, silver, silicon nitride, nickel chromium, propylene glycol Dynalene HC heat-transfer fluid, compressed helium and nitrogen, and diesel fuel.

    The ATST project would take place within an area that is already forty percent developed with roads, buildings, parking areas and walkways. .

    C. The Applicant and Its Partner Repeatedly Admitted that the ATST Project Would

    Have Substantial Impacts Which Cannot Be Mitigated.

    In its conservation district use application, the University admitted that construction of the ATST project would have a substantial adverse impact on cultural resources and viewplanes. It admitted that the

    ATST Project would have a substantial (major) adverse impact on cultural resources. Specifically, the proposed ATST Project would be seen as culturally insensitive and disturb traditional cultural practices conducted within the Region of Influence (ROI), which includes parts of HALE. Noise and associated construction-related disturbances would also have a major, adverse impact on cultural practices within the ROI. No mitigation would eliminate these impacts, but numerous mitigation measures would be employed to reduce such impacts as much as possible.

    It concluded that “the impact on visual resources at the Pu`u `Ula`ula (Red Hill) Overlook from the construction and operation of the proposed ATST Project is substantial because of its prominence in relatively close-up views.” The ATST “will cause a substantial visual impact on visitors to the summit area of [the National Park].”

    A chart in the final environmental impact statement (FEIS) for the ATST project summarizing the cumulative impacts from the addition of the proposed ATST project identified major, adverse and long-term impacts to: cultural, historic, archaeological resources; visual resources and view planes; and visitor use and experience. The FEIS unequivocally concluded that the construction and operation of the ATST project “would result in major, adverse, short-and long-term direct impacts on the traditional cultural resources” in the summit area. “Overall, there is a belief that to go forward with the proposed ATST Project would result in the desecration of a sacred site, with some equating the effects to building an observatory next to the Wailing Wall in Jerusalem or within the city of Mecca.” A report in the FEIS concluded: “Based on the information gathered during the course of this study and presented in this report, the overwhelming evidence, from a cultural and traditional standpoint, points toward a significant adverse impact on Native Hawaiian traditional cultural practices and beliefs.” The FEIS stated: “Changes in the viewshed during the operations phase would result in major, adverse and long-term impacts on the visitor use and experience from locations where the ATST project would be prominently seen.”

    The applicant’s partner, the National Science Foundation, which is funding the ATST, concluded that:

    At the Preferred Mees site, there will also be a major, adverse long-term impact on visual resources for [Haleakala National Park] visitor use and experience once the ATST facility is erected. The fully executed facility will be visible from Pu’u Ula’ula Overlook, the western edge of the Haleakala Visitor’s Center, the summits of Pa Ka’oao and Magnetic Peak, and along the Park road corridor nearing [Haleakala High Altitude Observatory Site]. These impacts will last for the life of the ATST, will continue to affect visitor expectations of the summit natural vistas, and no mitigation will adequately reduce the intensity of this impact.

    It also concluded: “Construction and operation of the ATST project . . . would result in major, adverse, short- and long-term, and direct impacts on the traditional cultural resources” in the summit area. “Mitigation measures would be implemented, and while helpful, they would not, however, reduce the impact intensity to moderate: impacts would remain major, adverse, long-term and direct.”

    D. Other Evidence Showed that the ATST’s Impacts Would Be Substantial.

    The applicant’s conclusion that the impact of the ATST project would be substantial was buttressed by the National Park Service, a former planning director, a professor of Hawaiian studies and the two previous superintendents of Haleakalā National Park. The National Park Service “believes that both during construction (short-term) and operation (long-term) the ATST will have a major adverse impact to the viewshed.” The BLNR itself concluded: “The cumulative effects on traditional cultural resources of past actions combined with the ATST Project would be major, adverse, long-term and direct.”

    III. Reasons the Permit Should be Invalidates.

    Kilakila ‘O Haleakalā argues that the 2012 conservation district use permit should be invalidated because the BLNR’s rules prohibit construction of a project that would have a substantial adverse impact to natural and cultural resources. The University admits that the ATST project will have a substantial adverse impact. The University also admits that its “mitigation” measures will not reduce the intensity of the impact to less than substantial. Approval of the ATST project undermines the purposes of the conservation district, which is supposed to tolerate the least amount of development in the entire state. The BLNR violated the law by considering economic factors in its analysis – which BLNR’s rules prohibit. In addition, the political pressure placed on the BLNR undermines basic notions of fairness. The deck was stacked from the beginning.

  • Opposition to ATsT hits ten year mark – legal battle still not resolved

    Opposition  began on July 12, 2005 when Ed Lindsey testified at the first public ATsT scoping meeting:

    “MR. LINDSEY: Ed Lindsey. This question is for Jeff the scientist. I appreciate your passion and your delivery for the importance of the study of the sunspots, as far as the scientific community is concerned. And for Jeff the architect, how many stories is your building?

    MR. BARR: If you identify it, you refer to it as something like a 10-story building.

    MR. LINDSEY: In other words, the building will be higher than the county building up on Haleakala, and that’s going to be pointed white; is that correct?

    MR. BARR: Correct.

    MR. LINDSEY: And that’s for scientific reasons and usage. Somehow, I feel like the fox is in the chicken coop asking the chickens when they want to be eaten, because I would rather have this project built in Colorado, Montana, New Mexico, or California, rather than here on Maui. That’s one of the problems that we have here on Maui being the best place for everything.

    So right now we find our local people in a pickle, not being able to even get housing, leave alone the lands. And so we have homeless Hawaiians here, and we have the federal government supporting a project such as this. And as worthy as it may be, there’s a complete disregard from the federal government for supporting the needs of the Hawaiian people and including the rest of the community over here on Maui. The impact on traffic is going to continue, the impact of construction is going to continue, the degradation of our cultural sites will continue. I just returned from a hearing where more cultural sites are being destroyed under the name of private ownership and private ownership rights. Now we have ceded lands, and I believe they are 5F lands; is that correct? In other words, another word for ceded lands is stolen lands, and it belonged to the Hawaiian people. And yet, there’s a continuous degradation in both the Hawaiian students, our Hawaiian culture, our Hawaiian elders, and the basic community fabric of our Hawaiianness.”  (see transcript)

    The Native Hawaiian Legal Corp estimates that it may take time for the Supreme Court to render its decisions. Because the case is still being decided, some people think nothing is happening. The Haleakalā cases have gone under the radar and most think the DKIST is a done deal. Not yet.

    Ironically, and unfortunately, we can literally say we have been fighting the project now for 10 years. And Ed Lindsey has since passed on.

  • Hawaii’s Board of Land and Natural Resources erred in approving a key permit

    From Civil Beat
    “Hawaii’s Board of Land and Natural Resources erred in approving a key permit for a controversial 14-story telescope currently under construction at the summit of Haleakala, the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled Friday.

    The decision marks a major victory for Kilakila O Halealaka, a Native Hawaiian group on Maui that has been fighting for several years against the University of Hawaii Institute of Astronomy’s telescope.

    Kilakila O Haleakala had requested a contested case hearing before the land board on the telescope’s conservation use permit. Instead, the board went ahead and approved the permit in December 2010 under then Chair Laura Thielen, effectively denying the group’s hearing request.

    Kilakila O Halealaka, represented by the Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation, sued the state, arguing that the permit should have never been issued because the land board was required to hold a hearing and allow the group to present their arguments against the project.

    Two lower courts previously ruled that they didn’t have jurisdiction in the case, allowing the permit to stand. But the Supreme Court disagreed, ruling that the courts did have jurisdiction in the matter and that there should have been a hearing before the board voted on the permit. NSF has approved funding of the project and the Final EIS has been issued. We are contesting their conservation permit with BLNR and public testimony will be accepted then. ”

    See decision here.

  • Videos: Cultural Genocide on Haleakalā

    Cultural Genocide on Haleakala, Maui by National Science Foundation & UH Institute for Astronomy.

    Please take time out to review this video on the destructive effects of the proposed Advanced Technology Solar Telescope on the spiritual practices of Native Hawaiians living in Maui. Please stop this cultural genocide.

    This video will be distributed to all parties involved in this cultural genocide to make them see how unjust this desecration is to the Spiritual Practitioners of Maui. In order to help in this fight please email Kilakila O Haleakala

  • Background on Telescope

    What is Proposed?
    The top of the telescope will be approximately 100′ higher than the summit. It’s base will be dug out 5 stories deep.

    Why Oppose the Telescope?
    Haleakalā National Park Superintendent Marilyn Parris said the park opposes a proposed solar telescope on the sensitive Haleakalā summit and called a draft environmental impact statement on the project inadequate. Read more

    “Somehow, I feel like the fox is in the chicken coop, asking the chickens when they want to be eaten; because I would rather have this project built in Colorado, Montana, New Mexico, or California, rather than here on Maui.

    That’s one of the problems that we have here on Maui being the best place for everything. So right now we find our local people in a pickle, not being able to even get housing, leave alone the lands. And so we have homeless Hawaiians here, and we have the federal government supporting a project such as this. And as worthy as it may be, there’s a complete disregard from the federal government for supporting the needs of the Hawaiian people and including the rest of the community over here on Maui.

    The impact on traffic is going to continue, the impact of construction is going to continue, the degradation of our cultural sites will continue. I just returned from a hearing where more cultural sites are being destroyed under the name of private ownership and private ownership rights.

    Now we have ceded lands, and I believe they are 5F lands; is that correct? In other words, another word for ceded lands is stolen lands, and it belonged to the Hawaiian people. And yet, there’s a continuous degradation in both the Hawaiian students, our Hawaiian culture, our Hawaiian elders, and the basic community fabric of our Hawaiianness.”
    Ed Lindsey

    Donate to the Legal Fees

    Send donations to:
    Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation
    1164 Bishop St Honolulu, HI 96813

  • UH Environmental Center Review ATST Supplemental DEIS

    June 22, 2009
    RE: 0792

    Craig Foltz
    National Science Foundation
    Division of Astronomical Sciences
    4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 1045
    Arlington, VA 22230

    Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement
    Advanced Technology Solar Telescope
    Makawao, Maui

    Dear Mr. Foltz:

    The National Science Foundation proposes to construct an Advanced Technology Solar Telescope (ATST) facility at the summit of Haleakala on 0.86 aces of land within the 18.166 acre University of Hawaii (UH) Institute for Astronomy (IfA) Haleakala High Altitude Observatories (HO) site. The preferred site is located east of the existing Mees Solar Observatory. The alternative site is another location within HO – a currently unutilized site known as Reber Circle. A No-Action Alternative is also analyzed in the document. The primary goal of the proposed project is to better understand solar magnetic activities and variability. The ATST Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement (SDEIS) is a joint Federal and State of Hawaii document prepared in compliance with Federal National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) regulations and the State of Hawaii Chapter 343, Hawaii Revised Statutes. The SDEIS is also prepared with the intent of evaluating potential environmental impacts associated with issuing a National Park Service Special Use Permit application to operate commercial vehicles on the Haleakala National Park road during the construction process and operational phase of the proposed project.

    This review was conducted with the assistance of Richard Mayer, Maui Community College; Jacquelin Miller, Environmental Center; and Ryan Riddle, Environmental Center.

    General Comment

    Our reviewers found preparation of a meaningful review of the SDEIS to be particularly difficult and time consuming due to the overall verbiage of its format and the extensive use of acronyms throughout the text. Throughout the document there are frequent duplications of sentences and incorrectly numbered figures and sections as a result of what appears to be cut and paste word processing. The document is also lacking in in-text references – an issue that makes cross-reference between the Executive Summary, Description of Affected Environment (Section 3.0) and Summary of Environmental Consequences Cumulative Effects and Mitigation (Section 4.0) particularly difficult. These factors all serve to frustrate the reader’s ability to objectively review the text. As for the plethora of acronyms, even a modest effort to write out the full name of the abbreviated term every few pages would make reading the document infinitely more user friendly.

    In addition to our general comment, we also have several specific comments.

    Electrical Systems (p. ES – 41)

    In regard to the provision of electrical power for the proposed project, the document states, “With this upgrade, there should be sufficient capacity to handle activities at the Mees or Reber Circle sites”. In this sentence the word “should” needs to be replaced with the word “will”.

    Other Required Analyses (p. ES – 45)

    In reference to environmental impacts from implementation of the proposed project at either the Mees or Reber Circle site the SDEIS states, “No major effects were identified that could not be mitigated to a less minor level”. This use of a double negative is confusing to the reader.

    Reasonably Foreseeable Future Actions (p. ES – 46)

    Mention is made of the proposed Satellite Laser Ranging (SLR) station that would be installed on the southwestern side of the Mees Solar Observatory. Is that action in any way related to or dependent upon ATST site selection? What possible effects could the SLR station have upon the ATST facility? Will the SLR station require an additional structure at the Mees site? What is the anticipated schedule for the implementation of the SLR project?

    Topography, Geology, and Soils (p. ES -53)

    This paragraph references using native soils and rock to “restore the pu`u at Reber Circle from its present truncated cone shape to a closely rounded natural appearance” thereby adding an estimated 24 feet of additional height. Given the concerns expressed by the Hawaiian community for soil stability, preservation, and general protection of the mountain, additional information on the potential impacts of such an earth moving/building project warrants greater explanation. This is mentioned as a possible mitigation measure and an alteration of topography yet it is not discussed further in Section 4.

    Project Location (p. 1-2)

    In the last paragraph on page 1.1 the total area of the project is given as 0.86 acres. The document states that this figure includes the leveling area, buildings, and paved pads. In Section ES-2.4 (p. ES-7) the SDEIS states, “The entire facility would include approximately 43,980 square feet of new building space within a site footprint of 0.74 acres.” We assume that the figure given in the executive summary does not include the entire leveling area and paved pads. It would be helpful to have a breakdown of the square footage required for each of the project’s various components.

    Site Selection Chronology (p. 2-2)

    In the first paragraph on page 2-2 the SDEIS states that the criteria that formed the basis for the elimination of the other 66 sites are discussed in Section 2.2.2 – Site Selection in Detail. There is no Section 2.2.2 in the text, however, there is a Section 2.3.1 titled “Site Selection in Detail”.

    Response to Public Comment Regarding Alternative Siting on Haleakala (pp. 2-6 – 2-7)

    The SDEIS inadequately explains why a space-based telescope is not completely evaluated as one of the alternative sites. It would seem that a space-based telescope would have many of the advantages that were found at Haleakala and would avoid the need for “adaptive optics”.

    The SDEIS limited its alternatives analysis to the 18 acre site operated by the UH IfA. A potentially superior site, perhaps in the saddle to the southwest of the 18-acre site, was only mentioned and did not receive detailed evaluation in the text. This alternative site could potentially avoid many of the visual problems of being located so close to Haleakala National Park. The site also may avoid some of the problems with Hawaiian cultural sites.

    Features of Infrastructural Design (pp. 2-19 – 2-20)

    In literature supplied at one of the scoping meetings it was mentioned that a potential solution to the considerable ground heat at the location would be the installation of a white apron extending approximately 10 meters from the telescope’s base. It is further stated that this white apron would provide numerous benefits such as reducing the height of the telescope, containing spilled lubricating oil and collecting water runoff. This design element is never discussed in the SDEIS. If the white apron were built, what would be the needed telescope height?

    Electricity (p. 2-39)

    In this paragraph the SDEIS discusses the electrical needs of the project. Were photovoltaics among the options considered? Given the local conditions this seems to be a suitable alternative.

    An upgrade to Maui Electrical Company’s (MECO) HO sub-station is mentioned in this section. However, no mention is made as to who will pay for the upgrade. Will this burden fall upon the general population of Maui?

    Also mentioned is a MECO-funded study that was conducted to identify economizing strategies for the proposed project. Can you summarize the potential strategies that were identified as a result of the study?

    Features of Infrastructural Design (p. 2-41)

    In Section 2.5.1 the SDEIS mentions the need for a new above ground fuel storage tank to support the back-up generator at the Reber Circle site. The document states that the proposed location and capacity of the tank have yet to be determined. It would seem that the volume of fuel needed to operate the emergency system over the expected life of an emergency can be calculated. What is the capacity of the Mees fuel storage tank and where is it located relative to the proposed structures?

    Haleakala Summit as a Traditional Cultural Property (pp. 3-8 – 3-9)

    On pages 3-8 and 3-9 the SDEIS states, “Native Hawaiian stonemasons erected the West and East ahu for ceremonial use by Kanaka Maoli at HO in 2005 and 2006, respectively . . . Although the purpose of this construction was to restore structures previously existing on Haleakala, the original structures were not necessarily in the particular locations where the new ahu were erected”. Is there any previous documentation (oral or written) of the use of the sites where the ahus were constructed in 2005 and 2006?

    Visitor Use and Experience (p. 3-46)

    In regard to a 2007 survey given to visitors exiting HALE the SDEIS states, “HALE has indicated that this survey is significantly flawed and likely biased and there are significant technical errors in the instrument and related reporting. Also, HALE indicated that the conclusions are based on an insufficiently designed and administered survey.” The SDEIS then seems to agree with the stated flaws while proceeding to draw conclusions from the results. Do plans exist for conducting a revised survey based upon recognized flaws in the 2007 survey? The SDEIS should not make the statement that “approximately 60 percent of respondents did not care if the new observatory was built” based on data that is recognized as being significantly flawed.

    Natural Hazards (p. 3-70)

    In this section mention is made of closing the Park road whenever weather conditions become critical and serious enough to warrant protecting human life. How often does closing of the road occur and for what duration in any given winter? Will this present a problem for construction or safety during erection of the facility?

    Earthquakes (p. 3-71)

    In the description of earthquake risk the SDEIS states, “Any repeat of the 1871 Lana`i earthquake would affect the project site. Mitigation of this risk is discussed in Section 4.17.14 – Natural Hazards”. Section 4.17.14 is titled Air Quality, not Natural Hazards. Did you mean Section 4.18.14?

    Land Use and Existing Activities (p. 4-6)

    This section mentions the FAA’s 2007 issuance of a Notice of Presumed Hazard regarding probable radio frequency shadowing at the FAA RCAG facility. This issue seems to be of critical importance and perhaps one of the most significant impacts of the proposed project. This topic is only briefly discussed in the text and possible mitigation measures are never mentioned. Solutions to this navigation concern must be fully addressed in the Final SEIS.

    Cultural, Historic, and Archaeological Resources (pp. 4-7 – 4-14)

    What is the time frame for the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) / Programmatic Agreement (PA) and Section 106 consultation process? This is an issue that should have been resolved prior to issuance of the SDEIS and one that should be fully addressed in the Final SEIS.

    Visual Resources and View Plane (pp. 4-29 – 4-75)

    The SDEIS does not mention the type of paint to be used in coating the exterior of the telescope facility. In scoping meetings it was pointed out that the white paint would be “extremely reflective” – much more so than the highly visible neighboring AEOS telescope. Consequently, the visual impact of the 143 feet high ATST will be amplified by its reflected radiance. The Final SEIS should discuss the impacts that this will have upon visual resources and view planes.

    Visitor Use and Experience (pp. 4-75 – 4-80)

    Of particular concern are the 250-foot crane and smaller 100-foot cranes that will be utilized for many years during construction. These visual and aural disturbances (individually and in combination) are most certainly a significant environmental impact. Over the course of 7 years over 7,000,000 visitors will be impacted.

    Communications Systems (p. 4-92)

    The SDEIS mentions that the location of the Maui base facility and ATST data repository has yet to be determined. How can one state that there is no impact to communication systems given that there is no description or evaluation of the facilities, equipment, and locations? In this section there is also reference to communication links via a fiber optic cable. The SDEIS states, “Connectivity from the site to the base headquarters would use existing dark optical fiber from the proposed ATST Project.” Does the connectivity refer to the military’s computer located in Kihei, to the Waiakoa Astronomy facility in Kula, to the new astronomy building constructed in Kula Malu in Pukalani or does it apply to all of these locations or none of these locations? This issue should be resolved in the Final SEIS.

    Employment, Economics, and Income (p. 4-112)

    The economic analysis provided in the SDEIS is lacking. Section 3.12.1.2 fails to describe the major economic activity on Maui, namely tourism. It fails to mention employment in tourism as well as tourism dependency. Additionally, Section 4.12.2 does not mention how the proposed project could potentially alter the visitor experience and therefore the economic benefits associated with Maui’s tourist industry. The Final SEIS should include this as part of the economic study.

    Effects of Past, Present and Reasonably Foreseeable Future Actions (pp. 4-127 – 4-128)

    There are additional new projects at Haleakala in addition to the ATST: Pan-STARRS, the NASA Transportable Laser Ranging System, and the AEOS Mirror Coating Facility. What are the cumulative impacts associated with these projects? Do they each have a separate CDUA? If so, how will the DLNR Board be able to consider cumulative impacts?

    Thank you for the opportunity to review this Supplemental Draft EIS.

    Sincerely,

    Peter Rappa

    Environmental Review Coordinator

    cc: OEQC

    Charlie Fein, KC Environmental, Inc.

    Mike Maberry, UH Institute for Astronomy

    James Moncur, WRRC

    Richard Mayer

    Jacquelin Miller

    Ryan Riddle

  • Sierra Club Testimony

    Haleakala Telescope Testimony

    Comments re SDEIS for

    ATST Project on Mount Haleakala

    Submitted to

    Dr. Craig Foltz, National Science Foundation

    OEQC Hawai’i State Dept of Health

    Mr. Mike Maberry, UH IfA

    Dr. Charlie Fein, KC Environmental, Inc.

    Submitted by

    Kathleen McDuff Individually and

    for Sierra Club Maui Group

    June 14, 2009

    Please accept these comments as a supplement to the comments that were originally submitted in writing in October 2006. The comments that were originally submitted will not be repeated here but are equally pertinent to this issue.

    Index

    Page

    Introduction 3

    1. Haleakala is not the only viable site for this project but it is the 5

    only site with cultural and historic preservation concerns

    2. The effect of this project on the ahus and on Hawai’ian spirituality 7

    would be devastating and would irreparably interfere with

    Native Hawai’ian Practitioners’ First Amendment rights

    3. Construction activities and excavation would cause irreparable 11

    harm to Native Hawai’ian cultural beliefs and practices and

    could cause irreparable harm to endangered species, the

    Maui visitor industry and protected historical sites

    4. The operational noise and the construction noise would 12

    cause irreparable harm to Native Hawai’ian Practitioners

    and could cause irreparable harm to federally protected

    endangered species and the Maui visitor industry

    5. This project is not in compliance with state and county laws and 15

    community plans and permit applications should not be approved

    6. This is a volcano – it will erupt again in the future – 16

    why wasn’t this important fact considered in the EIS process?

    7. Long term personnel will be brought in from the mainland and 17

    the few short term jobs that might be given to locals will not

    offset the major adverse long-term and/or permanent effects to Maui

    8. The visitors survey is seriously flawed 18

    9. The view planes to and from sacred Haleakala will be irretrievably 18

    damaged for the lifetime of the telescope, which will irreparably

    harm the rights of Native Hawai’ian Practitioners as well as Maui

    residents and the visitor industry on Maui

    10. You failed to properly and effectively comply with the 106 process 20

    which is federally mandated for this project in order to protect

    historical and archeological properties

    11. The SDEIS and NSF failed to properly consider the Hawai’ian 22

    ceded land issue and Native Hawai’ian rights

    Conclusion 23

    On Behalf of the Sacred Mountain Haleakala

    Hawai’ian Protocol for Sacred Places

    E Ui No Ka ‘Ae

    Ask Permission,

    E Mahalo Aku

    Give Thanks,

    E Komo Me Ka Hoano

    Enter With Reverence,

    I ka hele aku, e ho’oma’amau I ka wahi!

    When you leave, return it as you found it!

    INTRODUCTION

    The summit of Haleakala is sacred, not only to the Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawai’ians), but to the world at large. The beautiful painting above comes from the website of Sacred Sites, on which Haleakala is listed as one of the most sacred sites on Mother Earth. On the website Sacred Lands, Haleakala is called a holy site or wahi pana. The status of sacred Haleakala is listed on this website as “Threatened”, due to the proposed ATST telescope that is being planned on its summit. It is noted on this site of sacred places around the world:

    The summit and crater area of Haleakala is a sacred site to Native Hawai’ians, who have always been against construction of the observatories. In the early 1960s, Hawai’ians led peaceful protests at the state capitol in Honolulu, opposing the observatories and insisting that the mountain belonged to everyone—not just astronomers. Their demands went unheard.

    “Their demands went unheard.” Unfortunately, this is one of the familiar stories of the Kanaka Maoli. Their demands have gone unheard since their kingdom was illegally overthrown in 1893. It is time for this to cease. The people of Hawai’i are unique. They should not be lumped together with the Native American tribes, which are specifically given protection in the U.S. Constitution. The Hawai’ian people do not have a tribal council that speaks for them and which you, by law, are required to confer with. They must be dealt with differently and so far that has not occurred.

    Hawai’ians are very spiritual people. The sacred ‘aina (land) on which you are proposing to build your huge structure is a living being; it is their ancestor. The people who have been attending the 106 meetings on behalf of NSF acknowledge that they do not understand the cultural practices and beliefs of the Kanaka Maoli; as a result, the 106 process you have been conducting has not worked. In order for the decision makers of NSF to understand the significance of what the construction of this 143’+ structure will have on the Native Hawai’ians and their cultural practices, SOMETHING ELSE needs to happen. Your current 106 process is insufficient. The Native Hawai’ians are part of a Kingdom that was taken away from them over one hundred years ago, with very little remorse being shown. In the Apology Resolution that Congress enacted in 1993 to apologize for this illegal overthrow, it was acknowledged that

    …the Native Hawai’ian people are determined to preserve, envelope and transmit to future generations their ancestral territory, and their cultural identity in accordance with their own spiritual and traditional beliefs, customs, practices, language and social institutions.

    Placing the wants and desires of scientists (who can build their structure in a different location where there would not be an adverse effect to the culture and archeology of that area) over the desires of the Native Hawai’ian people who rightly demand that their sacred mountain not be further desecrated is clearly not following this directive by the members of Congress who chose to honor the Hawai’ians and their culture in an effort to reconcile the injustice done to them 100 years prior. It is past time for the Hawai’ian culture, the Hawai’ian people, and the Hawai’ian ‘aina to come first.

    1. HALEAKALA IS NOT THE ONLY VIABLE SITE FOR THIS PROJECT BUT IT IS THE ONLY SITE WITH CULTURAL AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION CONCERNS

    One interesting change from the draft EIS (DEIS) and the Supplemental Draft EIS (SDEIS) is that now it is being claimed that the Haleakala site(s) is the only site out of over 70 other sites that satisfies the criteria for this project. This is interesting because both in the DEIS and other documentation from the website of NSF it has been stated that all three final sites were excellent candidates. It was noted by the New Jersey Science and Technology Institute in an article on their website (Press release 973-596-3436, dated May 20, 2009 and titled World’s Largest Telescope at NJIT’s Big Bear Captures Sun’s Magnetic Field Better) that Big Bear Solar Observatory (BBSO), the world’s largest telescope located at Big Bear Lake, CA (one of the three final proposed sites for the ATST where there are no cultural or archaeological issues),

    is one of the premier land-based facilities supported by federal funding.    “We are already seeing images offering a better understanding of the Sun,” said Goode. “With this instrument we should be able to have a better understanding of dynamic storms and space weather—which can have dramatic effects on Earth.”    The new instrument has three times the aperture of the old telescope. It represents a significant advance in high-resolution observations of the Sun, since it has the largest aperture of any solar telescope in existence, said Goode.  Since it is an off-axis telescope, there is no part of the sunlight blocked by the telescope.  Other pluses include a marvelous location– high in a Southern California mountain lake.  

    Obviously, the ATST could be built at Big Bear Lake. They have just chosen not to. Serious questions remain regarding the scoring of the three final sites. For example, at Big Bear, CA, a site which received a “fail” designation for “seeing” characteristics, the testing was so flawed that less than 25% of the data sought to be evaluated was even gathered and analyzed.

    . . . if the seeing monitor would have been operational every day from sunrise to sunset 4,070,000 individual measurements could have been obtained. However, the number

    of data entries for BBSO is about 1,430,000. A substantial fraction of the missing data is related to the aforementioned observer profile. Other contributions are from complete

    system failures (July and November 2003) and bad weather conditions. Considering all data without a “failed ShaBaR” error flag about 910,000 data points could be used in this study. This number, however, is further reduced by about 60,000 data

    points, since some S-DIMM data were not properly transferred to the control computer.

    The Local Seeing Environment at Big Bear Solar Observatory, Angelo Verdoni and Carsten Denker1, New Jersey Institute of Technology, Center for Solar-Terrestrial Research

    This clearly does not present the profile of a serious scientific study. Likewise, the proposed La Palma site (which finished 2nd in the testing) was tested for two years and no potential cultural or archaeological problems were found there. Interestingly, at La Palma it was noted that the view plane of a specific peak called the Cumbrecita, which was a popular tourist attraction because of numerous hiking trails and scenic viewpoints – like Haleakala — was so significant to the people of the Canary Islands that it was determined during the testing process that this view plane must be protected. In deference to this conclusion, the proposed site of the telescope was relocated downhill. What a shame that you could not understand that the view plane of Haleakala is just as important to the Native Hawai’ians!

    It was noted that the La Palma site offers excellent high elevation “seeing” capabilities. Since La Palma finished ahead of Big Bear Lake in the testing process, and since Big Bear Lake can clearly be used for studying the sun flares, storms and weather – given that it already is – the La Palma site is a viable site. The fact that there may be a few less annual hours of sky brightness is something that can be worked out by the scientific community. At least one of the brilliant technological minds from our scientific community should be able to solve this glitch. Again, Haleakala is the preferred site, so you have chosen to say that it is the only site that will work. This is disingenuous – we need more honesty and more transparency. You are asking the Hawai’ian people to “mitigate” their spirituality even though it could destroy their practice, but you are not willing to mitigate your preferred site with your second or third choices. That is what could be termed as arrogance. You should also be straightforward when discussing how important this project might be to the scientific world, since you have apparently failed to disclose that similar information has already been gathered and is still being gathered elsewhere and still has not been put to use.

    2. THE EFFECT OF THIS PROJECT ON THE AHUS AND ON HAWAI’IAN SPIRITUALITY WOULD BE DEVASTATING AND WOULD IRREPARABLY INTERFERE WITH NATIVE HAWAI’IAN PRACTITIONERS’ FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

    There is insufficient information provided here regarding the effect upon the two ahus that have been set aside for Native Hawai’ian practitioners. First, from a personal point of view as a person who practices Native Hawai’ian spirituality up on the summit, the noise generated by the current projects is already very, very distracting. I was up on the summit for sunset for a group ceremony recently, and we were unable to do our meditations as they were meant to be because of the noise from some generator or fan at one of the buildings currently there. The noise we heard is before you add the operational noise from a building that will be much larger and that requires a huge air conditioning system and large fans to help keep it cool. Even though this was mentioned several times during the meetings and consultations and the written comments in 2006, the SDEIS has failed to address the impact this huge structure will have upon the ahus themselves. How can one meditate and practice spirituality in accordance with a tradition that integrates vibrations, meditations, prayers, communication with nature and spiritual energy and view planes, as well as communication with ancestors and spiritual beings, with this monstrous, noisy structure towering over you, as it will be at Pa’ele Ku Ai I Ka Moku. You infer that this is minimized by the fact that there is an unobstructed view outward from the mountain, but this shows how little you know about Hawai’ian spirituality and is a clear example of why the 106 process failed. This has been explained to you, but either you do not listen or you are not able to understand. Either way, the Hawai’ian people have not been represented as they are required to be during this federally mandated process.

    Furthermore, as I mentioned during the 106 consultations, the energy on the top of the mountain will be irreversibly damaged by the construction of this structure. I presented this statement during the 106 comments, but since it was not transcribed for the record, the person making the decision as to whether the funding will be granted would not be able to hear it. For that reason, I am reiterating it for the record herein.

    I am a Native American Spiritual Practitioner and I also practice Native Hawai’ian spirituality and have for many, many years. I am what is known by my people as a Dream Walker. I am able to journey back and forth between the physical and spiritual worlds. I have been very blessed by the spirits of this beautiful ‘aina and have been fortunate enough to have been gifted many visions from the ancients of this land as well. One of the gifts that I have received from these beautiful spirits was a very interesting vision. I was transported up to the summit of Haleakala and shown by the ancients what the kahunas felt when they were conducting their spiritual practices up on the sacred summit. I could literally see and feel the web that connected the different heiaus around the islands (including all of Maui Nui and the peaks of the island of Hawai’i) to the top of the summit. I experienced the incredible force of the energy that this web created and it was beyond description. My senses will never be the same. Then I was shown what that energy felt like today, after the buildings that are on the top of the summit have been constructed and after many of the heiaus have been destroyed, and the energy was much different. Much less powerful and a much different feeling. Then I was shown what the energy would be like after further desecration to the sacred summit – when this large 14 story telescope is constructed shadowing over the ahus — and I felt virtually nothing in comparison to what I experienced before. It felt like the Mountain was withdrawing. He was tired of fighting the negative energy on his summit and was very disappointed. At that moment, I was brought back down to my luncheon in Kahului, a much different person, with a lot to share with my companions. I hope you are beginning to understand that spirituality cannot be mitigation. You can’t put building after building (getting larger every time) up on a sacred mountain where spiritual practitioners go to pray and practice at a site where their ancestors sanctified the ‘aina over hundreds of years and created the energy for a special practice for themselves and their descendents, and then assume that you have not desecrated this holy, blessed site. It will never be the same. The desecration must stop – and it must stop now while there is still hope of bringing back that wonderful, special energy for Hawai’ian spiritual practitioners. Allowing Hawai’ian spiritual practitioners an ahu amidst the buildings that are violating the very spirit of the ‘aina is not the pono way. Stopping the desecration of this living mountain is pono. Allow the ancient energy to come back. Allow Native Hawai’ian Practitioners to reconnect with their ‘aina and with their ancestors in the way it was meant to be.

    You cannot build another structure upon this mountain and not interfere irreparably with the energy of this sacred mountain that is an integral part of Hawai’ian spirituality. I have heard from other Hawai’ian practitioners who say that their practice will be adversely affected to the point where they won’t even want to go up to practice anymore. Native Hawai’ian Practitioners should never have to go elsewhere to do their practice and they should never have to sacrifice or limit their own spiritual practices. This is their home. Haleakala is their ancestor. Practicing their spirituality in the way it is meant to be practiced is their right. Directly interfering with their First Amendment rights to practice their faith in the way it was meant to be and has been practiced traditionally for centuries is not only illegal – more importantly, under the Hawai’ian culture – it is not pono.

    This sacred summit has been sanctified by Maui himself, by the goddess Pele, and by the Kahunas and the Kupunas from ancient times through the present. It is a place where the tones of ancient prayer are balanced within the vortex of energy for spiritual manifestations. It should be honored by all. To take any action other than avoidance will irreversibly interfere with the United States and Hawai’ian Constitutionally protected spiritual rights of the indigenous people of Hawai’i. First Amendment religious rights are allowed to be absolute just because of their nature.

    If this project is approved and construction is started, Kanaka Maoli Practitioners will be prohibited from experiencing the full practice of their spirituality. I challenge the statement in the SDEIS on page 4-9 that although the project would have a major/adverse and long-term effect on cultural resources, it would have no effect upon the survival of Hawai’ian cultural practices and beliefs. It was further claimed that the proposed “mitigation” would lessen the major adverse effects on the Hawaiian culture to only “moderate.” On what evidence do you base this conclusion? Please provide us with documentation of the technical data you used to formulate this absurd deduction. It appears to be mere speculation that has no basis. It was acknowledged by the representatives at the 106 meetings that there are no Hawai’ians who work within the NSF or even within the Advisory Council for Historic Preservation. It was also apparent that none of the NSF representatives present at the meetings had any real understanding of the Hawai’ian culture or Hawai’ian spirituality, and when they were questioned on this by a Kanaka Maoli Kupuna, the response was that one of the objectives of the meeting was to try to obtain some understanding of Hawai’ian beliefs and culture. How, based upon your total lack of understanding of the spiritual and cultural beliefs of this indigenous culture, can you determine that your proposed “mitigation” matters would lessen the cultural adverse effects to “moderate”, when you have been told again and again by Kanaka Maoli that this is not so — you CANNOT mitigate spirituality.

    Anytime you interfere with Hawai’ian spiritual practices and prohibit the practitioners from practicing them in any way other than the way they were meant to be practiced, you are absolutely interfering with the survival of Hawai’ian cultural practices and beliefs in a major adverse long term (i.e. permanent) way. If this project is built, Native Hawai’ian Practitioners will be adversely affected the rest of their lives – they will not be able to practice their spirituality as it was meant to be at this sacred place where their ancestors conducted and taught prayers; where they connected to Wakea and Papa; and where they wove the vortex connecting all of the heiaus of Maui and even Hawai’i to this sacred summit where numerous Hawai’ian gods and goddesses are said to reside.

    3. CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES AND EXCAVATION WOULD CAUSE IRREPARABLE HARM TO NATIVE HAWAI’IAN CULTURAL BELIEFS AND PRACTICES AND COULD CAUSE IRREPARABLE HARM TO ENDANGERED SPECIES, THE MAUI VISITOR INDUSTRY AND PROTECTED HISTORICAL SITES

    You state in the SDEIS that a minimum of 250 truckloads or 125,550 cu. feet of sacred stone and native soil will be bulldozed up and relocated. Just digging into the lava rock, which is believed by many Native Hawai’ians to be the bones of Pele, is an affront to Hawai’ian spirituality. You may not move even one Pohaku (stone) without first asking permission of the stone itself, which is a living entity. If permission is not granted, you do not move the stone. To bring in a bulldozer to dig up and relocate 125,550 cu. feet from a sacred summit is an insult to the Hawai’ian culture. Your proposed “mitigation” of limiting this outrageous act to certain times of the day does not even begin to offset the offense. There is no nexus between the two. Again, this clearly shows a lack of understanding of Hawai’ian beliefs and culture. The land clearing, the demolition, the excavation, the grading/leveling, further digging into the ‘aina to bury electrical wires and cables, and the subsequent relocation of the soil and Pohaku from a sacred summit are all contrary to Hawai’ian culture and beliefs. Placing 21 caissons into sacred ground, bringing in three to five cranes well over 153 feet in height, and pouring cement onto and into sacred ground — all of this irreparably harms a living ancestor of the Hawai’ian people. Moreover, all of this activity irreversibly interferes with practitioners trying to meditate and practice in very close proximity. It is irreversible because spirituality must be practiced in the time and in the manner in which it was meant to be – you cannot make up in 2014 what you missed in 2011, because what you missed in 2011 may be gone forever. Hawai’ian spirituality is not just offering prayers to a Supreme Being. It is much, much more.

    In addition to the cultural issues, which are paramount in this case, at least 250 over-size capacity dump truck loads (it could be more), many more regular large trucks, delivery vehicles, van shuttles and passenger vehicles would travel the roadways leading to the construction site during the construction phase. The Park entrance station will have to be moved during the period to accommodate the huge structures that would be brought in. Not only is this historic roadway subject to potential harm during the construction period, but the 1.7 million visitors as well as kama’aina (native born) who travel up to Haleakala National Park and to the summit each year will be adversely affected in a major cumulative way. Visitors come up to the summit all day long – not just in the middle of the night to see the sunrise. This has not been addressed effectively`1111.

    There are endangered species that reside within Haleakala National Park. This is where the ‘ua’u have their burrows that they return to each year and incubate their young. There are many silversword plants along the roadway going up to the summit and on the summit itself. When I was there last week, I was amazed at the number that were blooming, and I could only see the ones that were in close proximity to the roadway – very near to the shoulder of the road that will be required to be widened in order to bring all the equipment up for construction. The nene are able to explore throughout the park and these beautiful spirits are always running across the roadway. The huge trucks and numerous vehicles coming and going will clearly present a danger to these endangered beings – there are only about 300 living nenes at this time – we cannot afford to lose even one.

    4. THE OPERATIONAL NOISE AND THE CONSTRUCTION NOISE WOULD CAUSE IRREPARABLE HARM TO NATIVE HAWAI’IAN PRACTITIONERS AND COULD CAUSE IRREPARABLE HARM TO FEDERALLY PROTECTED ENDANGERED SPECIES AND THE MAUI VISITOR INDUSTRY

    A related issue to the construction problems is the noise issue. As noted above, the operational noise from the existing buildings (generators, air conditioning systems and exhaust fans) as well as traffic and other stationary sources are already causing harm to the practice of Native Hawai’ian Practitioners. The additional operating noise from the proposed ATST will magnify this many times over. One possible mitigation proposed in the SDEIS was to limit the noise to certain times of the day. Native Hawai’ian spirituality is practiced for all of your life, all times of the day, all days of the year. It is not limited to day more than night or winter more than summer. It is affected, however, by where and how you practice. Practicing at sacred sites such as Haleakala is a vital part of the rites that practitioners perform. Quiet and solitude are also essential components of the practice. Chants, meditations, and deep reflections and journeys are also integral parts of the tradition, but they cannot transpire if outside noise is interfering with your consciousness.

    During the long construction phase, the heavy machinery, equipment and trucks, the excavation of the sacred soil and stone, the operation of the crane, the assembling of the structure, and the coming and going of the trucks and the personnel and other construction noises (which will be huge) will cumulatively result in Native Hawai’ian Practitioners being unable to practice in a meaningful way. How can you communicate with nature in a meditative state with a bulldozer excavating soil or grading nearby? It is stated in the SDEIS that there are “no noise-sensitive human receptors at HO”, so presumably, there shouldn’t be a noise problem on the site itself. Where exactly do you think the Hawai’ian ahus are located? Any noise other than nature is an intrusion upon spiritual practices so Native Hawaii’ian Practitioners are actually extra sensitive “noise sensitive human receptors” and should be treated accordingly.

    It is also ridiculous to state that a visitor standing at Red Hill is not within the area that will be affected in a major adverse way by the machinery noise of a bulldozer or other machinery, and thus concluding that the effect to visitors to the summit would be minor and short term. (Although in another section of the SDEIS –page 4-10 – you state that visitors standing on Red Hill, which is only 2500 feet away, would be affected in a long term way, while still limiting it to minor.) The construction phase is not short term for a visitor who comes to Maui for a two week vacation and has it marred by construction noises permeating their entire (and perhaps only) visit to the summit. What a terrible experience! Did you ask in your “visitors survey” whether the noise from a bulldozer a few hundred feet away would interfere with their experience at the summit? I was up at the summit recently and I asked visitors there at that time this question and every response I received was that it would indeed have an adverse effect upon their experience. In fact, one man who had come 3,000 miles with his girl friend to propose to her on the top of the summit that day said that even someone talking would have lessened the experience, much less if a bulldozer started up in the middle of his proposal.

    Limiting the noise-generating activities from thirty minutes prior to sunset and thirty minutes after sunrise will not mitigate major adverse impacts down to minor adverse as you have inferred, since there will be people suffering from the noises all day. Even at the critical sunrise and sunset peak times you are considering only limiting the noises above 82 dBA – a number that you have arbitrarily determined to be the criteria. This number seems quite high to me, and I assume to you as well, since you also determined that noise level changes above 20dBA are “major”. Red Hill is 2,500 feet away from the construction site – what about the Native Hawai’ian Practitioners who will be conducting spiritual practices next to the site. If the noise 2,500 feet away is considered to have a major effect upon the people visiting the overlook, this same noise immediately adjacent to where the Kanaka Maoli are trying to practice would be prohibitive.

    Further, drawing a conclusion that since that the roadways already have personnel traffic on them, then the increased vehicle traffic will only have a negligible adverse effect on ambient noise is not realistic. The construction trucks alone negate this. It also appears that the effect of noise upon the endangered species of the area is being minimized. The ‘ua’u are in their 1,000 known burrows between February and November of each year, not just during the April 20 to July 15 incubation period when the “mitigation” is being considered. If they are disturbed from their burrows prior to this time, there will be no incubation, and there will be no future birds. Construction of this telescope could and most probably will disturb one of the last two remaining major nesting colonies of the Hawai’ian petrel, which is on the brink of extinction. I repeat for emphasis because this is very important — the summit of Haleakala is home to one of only two major nesting colonies of the ‘ua’u left on earth (which consists of less than 1,000 birds). Vibrations and noise from the construction of the ATST could cause nesting burrows to collapse. The huge dump trucks, the cement trucks that will be going up and down the historic roadway, and the excavation of the summit itself during the construction phase will also have a major adverse effect upon these birds.

    5. THIS PROJECT IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH STATE AND COUNTY LAW AND COMMUNITY PLANS AND PERMITTING SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED

    Your statement that the ATST project is consistent with the goals of state, county and community plans is incorrect. The Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Upcountry Community Plan states on Page 32 Paragraph 8, that no building may be built over 35′ except for public use. Paragraph 8 is not an advisory statement, but an enforceable requirement. The Upcountry plan also states that a comprehensive Haleakala summit master plan needs to be implemented in order to promote orderly and sensitive development, which is compatible with the natural and native Hawai’ian cultural environment of Haleakala National Park.

    Maui County regulations prohibit construction of a building 14 stories high anywhere in the County. The project is clearly not consistent with the goals of Maui County. Additionally, after conducting numerous studies and hearing public comments from people throughout the island over a three year period, the General Plan Advisory Committee (a twenty-five member citizen panel appointed by the either the Maui County Mayor or County Council to set out recommendations for the Maui County General Plan for the County of Maui for the next 20 years) adopted a county wide policy plan that includes language to “immediately provide and encourage laws to preserve and enhance the summit of Haleakala with no new buildings.” [emphasis added] (Policy No. 5031) Finally, there is no comprehensive summit plan for Haleakala that protects the mountain’s natural and cultural resources, which is required by Hawai’i state law. This telescope is not supported by the community plan for the area; it is not supported by the county regulations; it is not supported by Hawai’i State law; and it is not supported by the community at large. Construction of this project demonstrates a total lack of regard for state and county law, ignores established planning practices, and will have a chilling effect on the enforcement of zoning laws in the future.

    6. THIS IS A VOLCANO – IT WILL ERUPT AGAIN IN THE FUTURE – WHY WASN’T THIS IMPORTANT FACT CONSIDERED IN THE EIS PROCESS?

    Described as “She-Who-Shapes-The-Sacred-Land” in ancient Hawai’ian chants, Pele is the goddess of fire and volcanoes. She is passionate, volatile and capricious. She was born of the female spirit Haumea (Hina) and the male spirit Kane-hoa-lani, who ascended from the supreme beings Papa and Wakea. Although she is currently residing in the Halema’uma’u crater of Kilauea, her previous home was here on Maui where she created sacred Haleakala. It was on Maui that Pele’s body was torn apart and the fragments heaped up to form the hill called Ka’iwi-o’Pele (The bones of Pele) near Kauiki Hill on the right side of Hana Bay. She has strong ties to Maui and most certainly to her crater Haleakala. Scientists call this sacred volcano “dormant” because her last eruption was in 1790. The term “dormant” simply means that a volcano is not currently erupting. The term itself does not provide any predictability of future activity. But note, the Soufrière Hills volcano on the Caribbean island of Montserrat was thought to be extinct before activity resumed in 1995. Similarly, Mount Vesuvius was considered extinct before it destroyed Pompeii in an eruption in 79 A.D. According to the USGS (United States Geological Survey) website, Haleakala “has witnessed at least ten eruptions in the past 1,000 years, and numerous eruptions have occurred there in the past 10,000 years. Thus, Haleakala’s long eruptive history and recent activity indicate that the volcano will erupt in the future.” See //hvo.wr.usgs.gov/volcanoes/Haleakala/ There is no mention in the SDEIS of a possible volcanic eruption as a natural hazard, even though that must be considered before you build on this sacred summit. There is a scientific system of classification known as Cladistics, which has utility in hazard assessment for sensitive facilities planned on or near known volcanoes. The SDEIS lacks this crucial evaluation. You must not ignore Pele, especially since you are blatantly disrespecting her and her creation by proposing to excavate and relocate her sacred bones on the summit during the construction phase of this telescope.

    7. LONG TERM PERSONNEL WILL BE BROUGHT IN FROM THE MAINLAND AND THE FEW SHORT TERM JOBS THAT MIGHT BE GIVEN TO LOCALS WILL NOT OFFSET THE MAJOR ADVERSE LONG-TERM AND/OR PERMANENT EFFECTS TO MAUI

    Although it has been a common talk story for the local proponents of the project that this project will bring many jobs to Maui, the facts state otherwise. Your 4.12 section acknowledges that the 25-30 key technical personnel that will work on the project will be brought in from the mainland, and that any local employment would be minor and short term. I see nothing in this to benefit Maui in a way that would offset the huge negative effects to our environment, our culture, our ‘aina, our historical sites, or our communities.

    8. THE VISITORS SURVEY IS SERIOUSLY FLAWED

    As noted in the SDEIS, Haleakala National Park (HALE) has “indicated that [the visitors survey you included in the SDEIS] is significantly flawed and likely biased and there are significant technical errors in the instrument and related reporting.” HALE further asserted that “the conclusions are based on an insufficiently designed and administered survey.” See 3-46. I concur and maintain that this survey should not even be considered in the Final EIS. If you do insist on including it, however, then you must also include the potential impact of your proposal that was part of this survey to allow those interested in touring the ATST facility to do so, which apparently is up to 75% of the 1.7 million visitors that come to the Park each year, as set out in the survey. Where is the impact study on the effect these people touring the facility will have on the noise, on the land, on the Kanaka Maoli Practitioners trying to practice at the ahus, on the parking lot, on the traffic, etc. You cannot make a bold statement that most visitors would not “care” if the facility is built based upon information gained from this flawed survey. Furthermore, you should not be able to use such faulty reasoning as a basis to try to offset the clear major adverse long-term effect this project will have on the Maui visitor industry, which is already declining.

    9. THE VIEW PLANES TO AND FROM SACRED HALEAKALA WILL BE IRRETRIEVABLY DAMAGED FOR THE LIFETIME OF THE TELESCOPE, WHICH WILL IRREPARABLY HARM THE RIGHTS OF NATIVE HAWAI’IAN PRACTITIONERS AS WELL AS MAUI RESIDENTS AND THE VISITOR INDUSTRY ON MAUI

    One million, seven hundred thousand visitors a year come to visit Haleakala. They visit Pa Ka’oao (White Hill) and they visit Pu’u Ula’ula (Red Hill), as well as the crater itself. The proposed telescope would be clearly visible from the Pu’u Ula’ula Overlook as well as most places in Haleakala National Park, including the roadway going up to the summit, beginning at the entry station. The three to five enormous cranes that will be used for constructing the massive building over a four year period will be visible from the crater itself. For Kanaka Maoli Practitioners practicing at the ahus, this enormous towering feature will even interfere with the view plane up to the stars at night — how ironic since you claim that the telescope is consistent with Hawai’ian culture and honors Hawai’ian astronomers who navigated by the stars. Prehistoric Polynesian navigators knew the star Arcturus as Hokule’a, the “Star of Joy.” Hokule’a is the Zenith Star of the Hawai’ian Islands today and is so important to the Native Hawai’ian culture that the voyaging canoe that was built to reconstruct the original Ancient Polynesians’ journey to Hawai’i is also named Hokule’a. If this telescope is constructed, practitioners at the ahus who look up to Hokule’a as part of their tradition will have their view interfered with by the towering telescope.

    The telescope will also obstruct the view plane of members of the community in many other places on the island. From Ma’alaea Harbor to the Hawai’ian Homelands to many other populated areas of Maui, the residents of Maui who look up to the summit of Haleakala for their sunrise and sunset prayers will have a huge white 14 story structure stick up at the center of their view plane. As noted in the SDEIS, based upon the overwhelming testimony presented by the community, there is a necessity for people to have an unimpeded view plane from mountain to ocean, particularly in the context of ceremonial activities. This essential view plane will be irreparably harmed if the ATST is constructed.  

    In these tough economic times our visitor industry is suffering greatly, and how can we allow anything to be built that will have a “major adverse long term effect” (in the words of the SDEIS) on the visitors coming to our island. How can we allow anything to interfere with the view plane of one of the most sacred mountains on Earth? As acknowledged in the SDEIS, there is no mitigation possible for the loss of view plane. As noted above, the view plane for the mountain at La Palma was important enough to preserve – why can’t the same be said of Haleakala? It seems as though you have little or no respect for our sacred mountain, and this is shameful! Haleakala should be treated with the respect it so rightly deserves. Mitigation should be practiced by the science industry by placing the project elsewhere.

    10. YOU FAILED TO PROPERLY AND EFFECTIVELY COMPLY WITH THE 106 PROCESS WHICH IS FEDERALLY MANDATED FOR THIS PROJECT IN ORDER TO PROTECT HISTORICAL AND ARCHEOLOGICAL PROPERTIES

    The summit of Haleakala is recognized as a very sacred place for the Kanaka Maoli. It is thought of as the Piko (navel), the center of Maui Nui O Kama (the greater Maui). The Hawai’ians consider the lava, cinders, and stones to be the sacred bones of Pele.

    As noted in the SDEIS, there are several reasons why the summit of Haleakala is a cultural resource in and of itself. It is eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) in several different categories. It is eligible as a “Traditional Cultural Property” (TCP) through consultation with State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) under Criterion “A” for its association with the cultural landscape of Maui as reflected in the number of known uses, oral history, mele and legends surrounding Haleakala. The attributes ascribed for Criterion A as noted in the SDEIS include

    (1) its consideration by Kanaka Maoli and many people throughout the world as a place exhibiting spiritual power;

    (2) its significance as a traditional cultural place because of practice – for those who live and visit here, the summit is a place of reflection and rejuvenation;

    (3) the mo’olelo and oli surrounding the summit present a cluster of stories suggesting the significance of Haleakala as a TCP;

    (4) its reputation as a place of healing; and

    (5) the remarkable “experience of place” associated with the summit.

    The summit is also eligible under Criterion “C” because it is an example of a resource type, a natural summit, a source for both traditional materials and sacred uses.

    There are too many archeological sites and resources to list here (doesn’t that tell you a story in and of itself), but please note that the burial sites, petroglyphs, platforms, trail segments, temporary shelters, cairns, and other features also qualify the summit for importance under Criterions “A”, “D”, and “E”. How can you even consider desecrating such an historically sensitive property?

    Due to the VAST historic nature of the summit of Haleakala, section 106 requirements for protecting historic properties apply. These requirements have not been met on this project. The NSF is required to evaluate the property for significance, access whether the project will have adverse effects on this historic property and determine whether the adverse effects can be addressed through avoidance, minimization and/or mitigation. As the personnel present at the meetings were repeatedly told during the 106 process, you can not mitigate the spirituality of the Kanaka Maoli. Avoidance is the only answer for this project. The summit of Halekala is sacred to the people of Hawai’i for many, many reasons that are interrelated to their Constitutionally protected spiritual and cultural practice, and this very important fact has been repeatedly ignored by the NSF. This premise is clear because repeatedly during the 106 process, after heartrending comments were offered in an attempt to help those present understand why any action on this land other than avoidance was contrary to Hawai’ian cultural beliefs, the response continually was “what can you propose that would mitigate that concern?” The Native Hawai’ian community clearly stated (again and again) that there is nothing that can mitigate the construction of this project on the sacred summit of Halekala.

    See, also reasons set out more fully in the Introduction and in Section 2 herein, as to why the 106 process as implemented thus far is not in compliance with federally required procedures that must be followed in order to protect historic properties.

     

    11. THE SDEIS AND NSF FAILED TO PROPERLY CONSIDER THE HAWAI’IAN CEDED LAND ISSUE AND NATIVE HAWAI’IAN RIGHTS

    There is no clear title to the lands on which this project is proposed, because these lands originally belonged to the Hawai’ian Kingdom until they were illegally turned over to the United States during the 1898 annexation. The nearly 1.8 million acres of land that were originally turned over were then passed into state possession when Hawai’i officially became a U.S. state in 1959; however, proper ownership of this land has still never been fully addressed. As noted in the Congressional Apology Resolution of 1993, neither the Native Hawai’ian people of Hawai’i nor their sovereign government ever consented to or received compensation for the illegal appropriation of the lands that belonged to the Kingdom of Hawai’i. This resolution further acknowledges that the indigenous Hawai’ian people never directly relinquished their claims to their inherent sovereignty as a people or over their national land to the United States, either through their monarchy or through a plebiscite or referendum. The referendum recognizes categorically that the health and well-being of the Native Hawai’ian people is intrinsically tied to their deep feelings and attachment to the land and recognizes that “the Native Hawai’ian people are determined to preserve, develop and transmit to future generations their ancestral territory, and their cultural identity in accordance with their own spiritual and traditional beliefs, customs, practices, language and social instructions.”

    There is no such acknowledgment in your SDEIS, because you do not understand or appreciate all that is integrated into Native Hawai’ian culture and beliefs. There is no provision or discussion in the SDEIS of the potential impact of being evicted from the site after the ceded land issue is finally decided in the courts. This is a clear error and omission that could have a huge bearing on the project itself and is absolutely something that must be considered by the NSF before a decision is made regarding whether to fund this project or not.

    CONCLUSION

    For numerous reasons, many of which have been noted herein and in my written comments to the DEIS in 2006, the only viable option for this project is to build it elsewhere. If you try to construct it on the sacred summit of Haleakala, such action

    • would illegally prohibit the exercise of Native Hawai’ian First Amendment rights
    • would cause irreparable harm to a federally recognized and world-renown historic site
    • would irreparably harm the Native Hawai’ian people of Hawai’i
    • would permanently interfere with the survival of Hawai’ian cultural practices and beliefs
    • could cause irreparable harm to federally protectived endangered species
    • could cause the visitor industry (an integral part of the Maui economy) to decline irreparably
    • could irreparably harm an historic roadway
    • could cause irreparable harm to archeological features intertwined with Hawai’ian culture and beliefs
    • could end up covered by lava when the volcano next erupts
    • could, after spending over $160,000,000, be evicted from the site after the ceded lands issue is decided by the courts (which it will be).

    The righteous (pono) way to handle this dilemma is to build the project at one of the other sites or in space, where it should have been built to begin with. Too much thought was given during this process to satisfying the needs of the scientists requesting the funding and too little thought was given to the needs, beliefs and way of life of the Hawai’ian people. It is clear that no one from the NSF, the UH IfA, or the people preparing the DEIS gave serious consideration to the spiritual and cultural beliefs and needs of the Hawai’ian people. If they had, they would have realized the totally devastating effect such a project would have on the Kanaka Maoli and, more importantly, on their living ancestor, the sacred mountain Haleakala, on whose behalf I humbly submit these comments. Now that you are aware of the irreparable damage it will cause, please do the right thing.

    Submitted with the sincere hope that this message will reach your heart as well as your mind.

    Kathleen McDuff

  • OHA Testimony

    STATE OF HAWAI`I
    Office of Hawaiian Affairs
    711 Kapi`olani Boulevard, Suite 500
    Honolulu, Hawai`i 96813

    HRD06/2048C

    October 2, 2006

    Dr. Craig Foltz, ATST Program Manager
    National Science Foundation, Division of Astronomical Sciences
    4201 Wilson Blvd., Room 1045
    Arlington, VA 22230

    RE: Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the proposed Advanced Technology Solar Telescope, Haleakalā , Maui; TMK: 2-2-007:008

    Dear Mr. Foltz,

    The Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) is in receipt of the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) issued September 1, 2006 for the Advanced Technology Solar Telescope (ATST), which the National Science Foundation (NSF) proposes to build on Haleakalā, Maui. OHA is the “principal public agency in this State responsible for the performance, development, and coordination of programs and activities relating to native Hawaiians and Hawaiians.” Hawai`i Revised Statutes (HRS) § 10-3(3). It is our duty to “assess the policies and practices of other agencies impacting on native Hawaiians and Hawaiians, and conduct advocacy efforts for native Hawaiians and Hawaiians.” HRS § 10-3(4). In this capacity, we offer the following comments.

    OHA appreciates that NSF has entered into formal consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife regarding the impacts on the endangered `u`au that live and breed within the preferred project site. We also commend the agency’s attempt to address environmental and cultural concerns through an EIS and the consistent use of correct Hawaiian spelling, including the usage of `okina and kahako.

    We have serious concerns with the DEIS, however. As further explained below, the DEIS was not used as a decision-making tool prior to NSF’s decision to build the ATST at Haleakalā, as required by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Council for Environmental Quality (CEQ) regulations. In addition, the alternatives presented in the DEIS do not represent a true opportunity for NSF to make an informed choice of location for the ATST, nor for adequate public input in the process.

    To rectify these deficiencies, OHA requests that NSF issue a supplemental draft EIS that includes the final three sites, which were identified by NSF as suitable for the ATST, as alternatives for comparison. This would provide decisionmakers and the public the opportunity to review all reasonable alternatives to the proposed action using environmental and cultural criteria, in conjunction with technical criteria, as required by NEPA. Until NSF completes a proper environmental review for the ATST project, OHA opposes this EIS and the project.

    Timing of the NEPA process

    NEPA “declares a broad national commitment to protecting and promoting environmental quality.” Robertson v. Methow Valley Citizens Council, 490 U.S.332, 348 (1989). To achieve this policy goal, NEPA requires that each federal agency consider the potential environmental impacts of all “major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment” through the preparation of an environmental impact statement. 42 U.S.C. § 4332. This directive is known as a “set of action-forcing procedures that require that agencies take a ‘hard look’ at environmental consequences.” Robertson at 350.

    Proper timing is essential for NEPA procedures to be effective in meeting the national goal of environmental protection. Pursuant to DEQ Regulations, an EIS “shall be prepared early enough so that it can serve practically as an important contribution to the decisionmaking process and will not be used to rationalize or justify decisions already made.” 40 C.F.R. § 1502.5. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has stated that “NEPA’s purpose is to ensure that federal agencies take a ‘hard look’ at environmental consequences before committing to action.” Ground Zero Center for Non-Violent Action v. United States Dept. of the Navy, 383 F.3d 1082; 1086 (9th Cir. 2004) (emphasis added).

    The requirement that NEPA procedures begin as early in the decisionmaking process as possible is not limited to specific final actions, such as the “siting, construction, and operation” of the ATST. DEIS at 1-1 (“NSF has prepared this EIS to evaluate the potential environmental impacts associated with the siting, construction, and operation of the Proposed Action.”) Rather, “[a]gencies shall integrate the NEPA process with other planning at the earliest possible time to insure that planning and decisions reflect environmental values, to avoid delays later in the process, and to head off potential conflicts.” 40 C>F>R § 1501.2.

    It is clear form the brief overview that follows that NSF did not comply with NEPA regulations by considering environmental effects of its proposed project “at the earliest possible time.” Rather, environmental and cultural concerns were considered only afterthe decision to construct at Haleakalā was made. All of the following information was taken from the DEIS at pages 2-1 through 2-3:

    • 1998 – Idea to construct an ATST was born; first criteria for defining an astronomically optimal site for the ATST were established
    • 2000 – International science community refined site criteria
    • 2001 – 72 potential sites chosen based on scientific criteria; after evaluation, sites were narrowed down to 6
    • 2002 – Physical testing of 6 sites began, and after a year, testing continued on 3 of the 6 sites
    • 2004 – Final report “concluded that Haleakalā met the criteria for the primary science outputs – annual required hours of good seeing and dark skies.”
    • 2006 – “Upon selection of Haleakalā as the proposed site, the procurement process was initiated in January to identify an environmental engineering company to provide support for the EIS process and related cultural studies and consultations.”

    By NSF’s own admission, environmental and cultural concerns were considered onlyafter the decisionmaking process was completed. OHA appreciates that extremely technical decisions must be made for the placement and construction of this telescope and that technicalities are best left to NSF scientists and experts. As a federal agency, however, NSF is bound by NEPA and DEQ regulations. CEQ regulations state, “[e]ach agency shall… [i]dentify environmental effects and values in adequate detail so they can be compared to economic and technical analyses. Environmental documents and appropriate analyses shall be circulated and reviewed at the same time as other planning documents.” 40 C.F.R. § 1501.2 Thus, it is absolutely clear under NEPA that environmental values are not to come second to economic and technical considerations, as occurred in this situation.

    Alternatives Analysis

    The heart of an EIS is its discussion of alternatives. 40 C.F.R § 1502.14. Every EIS must contain a “rigorous and objective” analysis of “all reasonable alternatives” to the proposed action, including a discussion of the “no action” alternative as a base-point to which the proposed action can be compared. 40 C.F.R. § 1502.14(a). Although not every alternative must be considered, “[t]he existence of a viable but unexamined alternative renders an environmental impact statement inadequate.” Citizens for a Better Henderson v. Hodel, 768 F.2d 1051, 1057 (9th Cir. 1985). The requisite alternatives are determined by the stated purposes and goals underlying the proposed agency action, however, “an agency cannot define its objectives in unreasonably narrow terms.” Carmel-by-the-Sea v. U.S. Dep’t of Transportation, 123 F.3d 1143, 1156 (9th Cir. 1997). The alternatives offered must “foster both informed decision-making and informed public participation.” California v. Block, 690 F.2d 753,761 (9th Cir. 1982).

    The purpose of the project appears to be the construction of a “powerful, flexible system that would serve the U.S. and international solar physics communities as the primary ground-based facility into the middle of the 21st century and beyond.” DEIS at 1-14. The alternatives presented in the DEIS must therefore reflect this purpose, while providing the decisionmaker all reasonable alternatives for comparison of technical and environmental considerations.

    OHA appreciates that the “no action” alternative was included in the DEIS, however, the other two alternatives offered did not properly take into account the environmental effects of the the project. The project will go ahead on Haleakalā, instead of using the NEPA process in deciding where the project will go forward.

    OHA is not requesting that NSF analyze the environmental impacts of all 72 sites identified by NSF as potential locations for the ATST. We do believe, however, that an analysis of the final three sites that remained viable options would b reasonable and sufficient to comply with NEPA. By analyzing the final three sites (Big Bear, Haleakalā, and La Palma) through an EIS, NSF will have a tool to consider not only the technical comparisons of the various sites, but the environmental and cultural impacts as well. This would allow NSF decisionmakers the opportunity to “reach enlightened policy decisions by taking into account environmental effects.” Environmental Defense Fund v. Massey, 986 F.2d 528 (D.C. Dir. 1993) (requiring NSF to comply with NEPA before implementing an organic waste incineration program in Antarctica).

    Proffered Solution

    In summary, to cure the deficiencies with the timing and alternatives requirements of NEPA and CEQ regulations, OHA strongly suggests that NSF issue a supplemental draft EIS that compares the environmental impacts of the final three sites that were previously analyzed by NSF for technical criteria only. This will allow NSF decisionmakers to consider all required factors before a decision is made as to where the ATST should be built. It will also allow the public the opportunity to properly respond to and comment on the proposed project, as envisioned by Congress through NEPA. We note that incorporating proper alternatives into a final EIS is not satisfactory, because a legally sufficient EIS will involve significant changes on which the public must have an opportunity to comment. See, Block, 690 F.2d at 770.

    Thank you for this opportunity to comment and for continuing to work with our Maui community resource coordinator, Thelma Shimaoka, regarding the cultural impacts of the ATST. We look forward to reviewing your supplemental DEIS. If you have any further questions or concerns please contact Koa Kaulukukui at [phone and email omitted to prevent spam].

    Sincerely,

     

    Clyde W. Nāmu`u
    Administrator

  • Haleakala Telescope Testimony by Dick Mayer

    To: Dr. Craig Foltz, ATST Program Manager June 22, 2009
    National Science Foundation, Division of Astronomical Sciences
    4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 1045, Arlington VA 22230

    From: Professor (Emeritus) Dick Mayer, Economics and Geography Tel.
    [phone/email/address]

    RE: FED./STATE SUPPLEMENTAL D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)

    1. The views that I express below are my own and not necessarily those of any organization or association.

    2. SCOPING MEETINGS There were problems with the scoping meetings: the public was not well informed about the actual height of the telescope facility and the attached service building. In fact, it appears that there was an actual attempt to mislead the public. The photos and sketches shown to the public were all aerial shots which gave the impression that the telescope was actually shorter than the top of the mountain. (The telescope actually will rise to a height about 100′ above the highest natural point on the mountain!!) Furthermore, when asked the height of the telescope at the scoping meeting, the figure given by the ATST spokesperson was approximately 93 feet; the actual height is approximately 50 percent greater.

    Because the public was mis-lead on the height, it was less able to comment accurately on the enormous visual impact of the planned facility. It was not until several weeks later that the Maui News reported accurately on the actual telescope height, too late for the scoping meetings.

    3. SITE SELECTION It would seem that a space-based telescope would have many of the advantages which were found at Haleakala and would avoid the need for “adaptive optics”. The Sup-DEIS does not adequately explain why the space-based telescope is not completely evaluated as one of the alternative sites. A space-based solar telescope should BE included in the Final EIS as an alternative site.

    4. SITE SELECTION The Sup-DEIS has limited its evaluation only to the 18 acre site operated by the UH IfA. The Sup-DEIS then attempts to make a careful analysis

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 2

    between two almost similar sites, both in the 18 acre HO location. Consequently, a potentially superior site, perhaps in the saddle to the southwest of the 18 acre site, was only mentioned and certainly was not seriously evaluated. This alternative site could potentially avoid many of the visual problems of being located so close to the Haleakala National Park. The site also may avoid some of the problems with Hawaiian cultural sites. It was prematurely dismissed. Being located in the 18 acre site requires a CDUA permit, just as a site in the “saddle” would require a CDUA permit.

    5. HEAT AVOIDANCE CAUSING EXCESSIVE HEIGHT Despite the fact that since 1996 there has been a 35′ height limit in the Upcountry Community Plan district, the proposed telescope would violate this ordinance. It would be the tallest building in Maui County. The Sup-DEIS describes the telescope’s “143 feet height” as being necessary to avoid being too close to the ground where there is considerable heat coming off of the dark lava rock.

    In literature supplied at one of the scoping meetings it was mentioned that a potential solution to the considerable ground heat would be the installation of a white apron extending approximately 10 meters from the telescope’s base. It is further stated that this white apron would provide numerous other benefits, such as containing spilt lubricating oil and collecting water runoff.

    Unfortunately, this white apron was not discussed in the Sup-DEIS. If it had been included in the building design, evaluated and discussed, it might be possible to reduce the height of the telescope, maybe also the proposed illegally tall service building, and perhaps even the overall cost of the project. If the white apron were built, what would be the needed telescope height?

    6. SPIRITUAL AND CULTURAL” SIGNIFICANCE I will limit my own comments about the “spiritual and cultural” significance of the Haleakala Summit site because

    so many others with far more knowledge will be commenting on this matter. However, I would encourage those who are evaluating the Final EIS, to consider

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 3

    their own personal reaction if this telescope was being proposed to be located on the Mall in Washington D.C. in front of the Lincoln Memorial, or perhaps at a site considered sacred to members of their own religion, such as on Calvary Hill in the city of Jerusalem, or besides the Wailing Wall also in Jerusalem, or in the city of Mecca. (Would these sites even be considered as potential locations for a grand scientific experiment that might benefit all of humankind? If the answer is “NO!”, then why is Haleakala even being considered?)

    7. LAND OWNERSHIP When discussing the ownership of these lands, the Sup-DEIS indicates that the University of Hawaii was given these lands by Gov. Quinn’s Executive Order # 1987. The Sup-DEIS states that the U. H. is now the “fee owner” of these lands.

    What the Sup-DEIS neglects to point out is that the Hawaii State Governor may not have had the right to give away these lands in 1961 since neither he nor the State of Hawaii owned the lands. The lands at the summit of Haleakala are “ceded lands” which have numerous implications, not the least of which is the need by users to pay a “fair-market” rent. The University of Hawaii pays only $1 per year for the whole 18+ acres. Furthermore, the courts may rule someday that users of these lands may need to pay reparations to the Hawaiian Kingdom that was overthrown in January 1893 by United States naval forces.

    8. OFF-SITE CONNECTIONS AND CUMULATIVE EFFECTS Several references are made in the Sup-DEIS to physical connections to off-site facilities. The references are to some kind of “base” for communication, to an off-site computer “server”, and to a vague facility at an undetermined site where many of the telescope’s workers will be employed. Although the Sup-DEIS refers to these locations, there is no description or evaluation of these off-site locations. In fact, the Sup-DEIS says that

    the details of the connectivity have not yet been determined. How then can the Sup-DEIS claim in the same section that there is “NO IMPACT”?

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 4

    Is the connectivity referring to the military’s computer located in Kihei (South Maui)? To the Waiakoa Astronomy facility in Kula? To the new astronomy building constructed in Kula Malu in Pukalani? All of these locations? Or none of them?

    Until the cumulative impacts of this project and its use of other sites, the EIS will be incomplete. For example, is the design and construction of the “military financed” Kihei-Upcountry Highway connecting the ATST telescope to the Kihei computer actually a portion of this project?

    Without the often mentioned support sites (outside the 18 acre site) being located, described and evaluated, the section on and analysis of “cumulative impacts” is woefully incomplete.

    9. MILITARY RELATED COMPONENTS and SECURITY IMPLICATIONS In several places within the Sup-DEIS, there are indications that there may be military connections to this project. For example, there is a discussion of communication links via a fiber optic cable. Does this mean that this telescope will be digitally tied to the military computer located in Kihei (South Maui)? There was also mention made that the telescope lenses will periodically be serviced by the Air Force’s Mirror Coating Facility which is located at the Hawaii Observatory. Finally, the scientific results from the ATST’s observation and analysis of the “solar mass ejections” and solar wind would be of great use to the United States’ emerging “militarization of space”. Is the ATST actually part of the federal government’s military program?

    The close ties of the ATST to the military will result in potential security concerns for the facility, the workers, the “connections” to other facilities, and one million plus tourists who visit the area. Security issues must be addressed in the Final EIS.

    10. SCOPING MEETING TRANSCRIPTS The Final EIS should contain the complete, unedited, transcripts from each of the Sup-DEIS meetings held in 2009. During those meetings much valuable testimony was given by the public; a recorder was present and took down all the comments verbatim.

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 5

    11. ELECTRICITY UPGRADES AND THE MAUI RESIDENTS An upgrade to MECO’s HO sub-station is mentioned. However, no mention is made as to who will pay for this upgrade. Will the burden fall on the general population of Maui who will see the capital cost of MECO rise, with a subsequent increase in resident’s electric power rates?

    12. CUMULATIVE IMPACTS FROM OTHER NEW FEDERAL and UH ACTIVITIESThere are other projects in addition to the ATST: Pan-STARRS; NASA Transportable Laser Ranging System; and the AEOS Mirror Coating Facility.

    Are there traffic concerns? Biological considerations? Cultural considerations? Disrupted view corridors? Etc.? Does each of them have a separate CDUA? If yes, how will the DLNR Board be able to consider cumulative impacts?

    Since these are all on the same University of Hawaii leased site, Hawaii HRS 343 requires a cumulative impact review/analysis.

    13. HALEAKALA NATIONAL PARK IMPACTS A major deficiency of the Sup-DEIS is the inadequate treatment of the effects of the ATST on the Haleakala National Park. The National Park Service will be contributing its own comments on the DEIS. However, I would like to reinforce their concerns. The Sup-DEIS has trivialized the impact of the ATST on the disruption to the view plane and the reduced quality of the tourist (and resident) experience.

    The Red Hill lookout is the highest point on Haleakala. The proposed ATST site is a mere 1,500 feet from Red Hill where over one million tourists come each year to

    view one of the most beautiful and unique views on the planet. Even the astronauts who were planning to go to the moon came to this location because of its very special environment. Unfortunately, the Sup-DEIS grossly underestimates the impact of the “in-your-face” 143 feet high telescope and the adjacent service building. Maui County law in the form of the Upcountry Community Plan states as a Land Use Policy (P. 18),“Recognize the value of open space, including agricultural lands and view planes to preserve the region’s rural character.”

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 6

    Furthermore, the Red Hill overlook is located within the 55 db noise contour emanating from the 7 years of the ATST construction. Although this is noise level revealed, it is in “exceedance of the state standard for maximum permissible daytime sound levels in class A zones”. The Sup-DEIS describes this as being only disturbance. It is NOT!

    And furthermore, there is the matter of the 250′ crane and a number of smaller 100′ cranes that will be utilized for many years during construction. These will be a further blight on the visual enjoyment of this very special place.

    These visual and aural disturbances (individually and in combination) at the major viewing site in a United States National Park are unacceptable, and definitely a most significant environmental impact. The fact that the Sup-DEIS trivializes these impacts (in the form of its flawed visitor survey) seriously undermines the quality of the entire document. Over the course of 7 year construction period, over 7,000,000 visitors will be impacted.

    14. VISITOR SURVEY IS FLAWED As noted in the Sup-DEIS (See 3-46), Haleakala National Park (HALE) has “indicated that [the visitors survey you included in the SDEIS] is significantly flawed and likely biased and there are significant technical errors in the instrument and related reporting.” HALE further asserted that “the conclusions are based on an insufficiently designed and administered survey.”

    This survey should not even be considered in the Final EIS. If you do insist on including it, however, then you must also include the potential impact of your

    proposal that was part of this survey to allow those interested in touring the ATST facility to do so, which apparently is up to 75% of the 1.7 million visitors that come to the Park each year, as set out in the survey. Where is the impact study on the effect these people touring the facility will have on the noise, on the land, on the Kanaka Maoli Practitioners trying to practice at the ahus, on the parking lot, on the traffic, etc?

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 7

    You cannot make a bold statement that most visitors would not “care” if the facility is built based upon information gained from this flawed survey. Furthermore, you should not be able to use such faulty reasoning as a basis to try to offset the clear major adverse long-term effect this project will have on the Maui visitor industry, which is already declining.

    15. SUPER WHITE REFLECTIVE PAINT The Sup-DEIS is silent on the type of paint to be used in coating the exterior of the telescope facility. However, it was made clear in previous meetings that a “super-bright” white paint was being utilized on the telescope’s exterior.

    I could find no discussion in the Sup-DEIS of the impact of that white paint on the visibility of the telescope. In discussions during the scoping, it was pointed out that

    the white paint would be “extremely reflective”, much more so than the highly visible, neighboring AEOS telescope. Consequently, the visual impact of the 143 feet high ATST will be amplified by its reflected radiance. The final EIS must report on this undesired effect.

    16. ECONOMIC IMPACTS ON MAUI’S TOURIST INDUSTRY It is expected that an EIS will examine carefully the economic impacts of a proposed project. The ATST Sup-DEIS is woefully lacking in economic analysis. It does not even describe the major basic economic activity on Maui, the industry which brings in most of the income and provides most of the jobs, namely tourism. Is there even a reference to tourism, tourist employment, and tourism dependency? NO!

    If the tourism industry had been accurately considered in the Sup-DEIS, it would have indicated that Maui Island has for many years been considered the “Number One” tourist destination island in the whole world. (See last ten years of Conde Nastmagazine’s selections.) Tourists come to Maui for both the special cultural experience as well as the incredible scenic beauty of the island. The summit of Haleakala is probably the most visited spot on the island, and at the summit lookout the ATST will be a direct assault on that tourist experience. There will be

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 8

    consequences: a serious erosion of the visual experience. This is not just some mere “subjective” observation, as the Sup-DEIS attempts to portray the view plane. It is why more than a million people each year come to see the views. It is why there is a substantial Haleakala summit tour business.

    Moreover, the tranquility of the overlook will be engulfed by the nearby construction noise. And finally, and not insignificantly, tourist traffic up the mountain will be seriously impacted by the very heavy, slow-moving concrete trucks and other even heavier and wider trucks that will be unable to pull-over to allow a long line of tourist cars to pass.

    All of these effects will impact the quality of Maui’s tourism industry. Consequently, there may be fewer tourists coming to Maui, less money being spent and fewer jobs available. It is inappropriate that the Sup-DEIS has totally neglected to even mention this, Maui’s major industry. I expect the Final EIS to comprehensively study the impact of the ATST on the tourist industry.

    In this regard the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan states (P. 12),“this Community Plan region is the home of significant resources, including water shed areas and the Haleakala National Park, which is significant in terms of its

    resource preservation, enhancement and protection values. From an economic standpoint, the National Park is viewed as an important component of the region’s economy.”

    17. EXCAVATED SOIL There seems to be some confusion as to what will happen with the excavated soil from the proposed site. It is suggested that it will be deposited at a nearby site. However, the site has been given two different functions: as a site for soil placement, and as the “construction staging” area. Which is it?

    18. RESIDENT AND COMMUNITY PREFERENCE FOR RURAL AMBIENCE There is a strong feeling among residents in the surrounding community that this whole area

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 9

    should NOT be impacted by urban, large or industrial-type facilities. These feelings have been expressed in the vision of the Kula Community Association (which includes the ATST site within its community). The KCA vision statement reads as follows: “The vision of the Kula Community Association is to preserve open space, support agriculture, maintain a rural residential atmosphere, and to work together as a community.”

    These sentiments also form a basis for the legally adopted and enforceable Maui County General Plan (of which the Upcountry Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan is a component). The Community Plan governs the use of land in the district which includes the summit of Haleakala and the ATST site.

    It states as a problem (P. 11), “LOSS OF RURAL CHARACTER. One of the primary attributes which make the Makawao-Pukalani-Kula region unique to the island is the rural and serene environment which defines Upcountry Maui’s character. The loss of this rural ambiance is of significant concern to the region’s residents.”

    Furthermore, as a Policy and Objective under Economic Activity, it states on page 17,“Recognize the rural, open space character of the Upcountry region as an economic asset of the island.”

    Consequently the proposed ATST would violate Maui County law.

    19. MASTER PLAN FOR THE WHOLE SUMMIT AND FOR ALL THE ACTIVITIES The (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan which governs the use of land in the region that includes the ATST site, the whole UH IfA site, the Haleakala summit, and the Haleakala National Park indicates the direction for use of the environment. It states clearly on Page 24 as the Goal for the Environment,

    “ENVIRONMENT Goal Protection of Upcountry’s natural resources and environment as a means of preserving and enhancing the region’s unique beauty,

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS – ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 10

    serenity, ecology, and productivity, in order that future generations may enjoy and appreciate an environment of equal or higher quality.”

    To achieve this Goal, it specifies an Objective and Policy (P. 25), “Encourage Federal, State and County cooperation in the preparation of a comprehensive Haleakala summit master plan to promote orderly and sensitive development which is compatible with the natural and native Hawaiian cultural environment of Haleakala National Park.”

    In the year 2001 the Maui County Council passed Resolution 01-45 entitled, “Urging the State of Hawaii to Fund Master Planning for Haleakala”. Unfortunately, to-date the Master Plan is only for the 18 acre IfA site. There is an obvious need to plan not just the IfA 18 acres, but the whole summit region of Haleakala. Only in this way will the interaction among the various activities be known and the problems mitigated. This Supplement to the original DEIS has yet to grasp the multiple impacts of the ATST on other activities at the summit.

    20. DRAFT MAUI ISLAND PLAN After conducting numerous studies and hearing public comments from people throughout the island over a three year period, the General Plan Advisory Committee (a twenty-five member citizen panel appointed by the either the Maui County Mayor or County Council to set out recommendations for the Maui County General Plan for the County of Maui for the next 20 years) adopted a county wide policy plan that includes language to “immediately provide and encourage laws to preserve and enhance the summit of Haleakala with no new buildings.” [Emphasis added] (Policy No. 5031).

    21. 35-FOOT HEIGHT LIMITATION THROUGHOUT THE REGION The height and the scale of the proposed 143′ ATST facility and the approximately 70′ adjoining service building violate an important design guideline contained within the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan. In fact, the Sup-DEIS totally

    FEDERAL/STATE Sup-DEIS -ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory) Dick Mayer P. 11

    21. 35-FOOT HEIGHT LIMITATION THROUGHOUT THE REGION The height and the scale of the proposed 143′ ATST facility and the approximately 70′ adjoining service building violate an important design guideline contained within the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan. In fact, the Sup-DEIS totally ignores this guideline, perhaps because its impact can NOT be mitigated by the proposed project. The guideline (Page 30) reads as follows, “Enforce a two-story or 35-foot height limitation throughout the region, except for public/quasi-public uses such as auditoriums, gymnasiums, and fire stations.”

    Since I was vice chairman of the Citizens Advisory Committee that recommended the restrictive guideline, I know that the guideline clearly applies to the ATST facility. Although it is a publically owned facility, it is not one used by the general public as do those in the examples given (auditoriums, gymnasiums, and fire stations).

    Since the Community Plan is a Maui County ordinance and because a CDUA permit requires that every application must conform to ALL State and County ordinances, the ATST would be ineligible to receive a CDUA permit from DLNR.(NOTE: Neighboring HO telescopes, such as the 110′ AEOS telescope were permitted before the adoption of the 35′ maximum in the 1996 Community Plan.)

    Mahalo for your consideration of these comments; I look forward to the appropriate revisions in the Final EIS.

    Sincerely,

    Prof. (Emeritus) Richard “Dick” Mayerdickmayer@earthlink.net

    1111 Lower Kimo Dr. Kula, Maui, HI 96790

    CC. Office of Environmental Quality Control, Hawai’i Dept. of Health

    Mr. Mike Mayberry, UH IfA

    Dr. Charles Fein, KC Environmental Inc.