Author: fueji

  • UH Comments

    UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI`I AT MANOA
    Environmental Center
    December 9, 2006
    RE:0755

    Dr. Craig Foltz
    National Science Foundation
    Division of Astronomical Sciences
    4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 1045
    Arlington, VA  22230

    Dear Dr. Foltz:

    Draft Environmental Impact Statement
    Advanced Technology Solar Telescope (ATST)
    Haleakalā, Maui

    The NSF, through an award to the National Solar Observatory (NSO), is proposing to fund construction of the proposed ATST at the University of Hawai‘i Institute for Astronomy (IfA), Haleakalā High Altitude Observatory (HO) site, on the island of Maui, Hawai‘i.  An extensive campaign of worldwide site testing has identified Haleakalâ Observatory as the optimal location for this next-generation solar observing facility.  With its unprecedented 4.2-m (165-inch) aperture, advanced optical technology, and state-of-the-art instrumentation, the proposed ATST would be an indispensable tool for exploring and understanding physical processes on the sun that ultimately Advanced Technology Solar Telescope (HRS 343 DEIS) affect Earth.  The telescope enclosure and a support facility would be placed at one of two identified sites within the existing observatory boundaries.  The DEIS addresses both of these sites and the potential environmental impacts of on-site construction, installation, and operation of this proposed new solar telescope.

    This review was conducted with the assistance of Kiope Raymond (Hawaiian Studies, Maui Community College) and Richard Mayer (Economic/Geography Emeritus, Maui Community College).

    General Comment

    Our main concern is with the Cultural Impact Assessment and we will comment on that issue at some length below.  We would like to acknowledge that the site chosen is in an area that was set aside for research in astronomy.  However, the summit of Haleakalā was sacred to Hawaiians long before the site was designated.  However, we would encourage those who are evaluating the FEIS, to consider their own personal reaction if this telescope was being proposed to be located on the Mall in Washington D.C. in front of the Lincoln Memorial, or perhaps at a site considered sacred to members of their own religion, such as on Calvary Hill in the city of Jerusalem, or besides the Wailing Wall also in Jerusalem, or in the city of Mecca.

    In addition to our comments on cultural impacts, we have noted a number of other issues to be addressed in the FEIS following our lengthy discussion on cultural impacts.

    Cultural Impact Assessment

    Our major observation is the overall lack of adequate adherence to the June 2004 Hawai`i State Guidelines for Assessing Cultural Impacts of the Office of Environmental Quality Control (OEQC).  There are six general recommendations the Environmental Council makes to preparers of assessments analyzing cultural impacts.  There are also 11 protocols that should be addressed in the assessment concerning cultural impacts.  We believe that most recommendations and protocols outlined by the OEQC are inadequately addressed.

    Of equal concern is the ample evidence that the Cultural Assessment is inadequate in providing enough information to compel a reader to clearly understand the spiritual sacredness and cultural relationship of Hawaiians to Haleakalā as a whole; and the summit area in particular.

    Finally, there is evidence of an awkward bias on the part of the authors of the Cultural Assessment, apparent in their language and conclusion that does not seem appropriate when assessing a cultural impact.  The bias indicates a predetermined finding that, “…no matter what the objections to the building of the ATST on Haleakalā, it will get built anyway….”  We point out that that decision to implement the proposed action does not rest with the preparer(s) of the Cultural Assessment!  Therefore, because of the inadequate and/or biased preparation of the document, we believe that federal and state decision makers cannot make a sound, fully informed decision regarding the cultural impacts of ATST.

    Specific Objections:

    • Inadequate discussion with Native Hawaiian organizations.  Glaring by its omission is lack of contact with the United States Office for Native Hawaiian Affairs, Department of the Interior; created in 2005:  “SEC. 4. ESTABLISHMENT OF THE UNITED STATES OFFICE FOR NATIVE HAWAIIAN AFFAIRS (a) IN GENERAL – There is established within the Office of the Secretary of the Department of the Interior the United States Office for Native Hawaiian Affairs.  (b) DUTIES OF THE OFFICE – The United States Office for Native Hawaiian Affairs shall – (1) effectuate and coordinate the special trust relationship between the Native Hawaiian people and the United States through the Secretary, and with all other Federal agencies.” (//www.doi.gov)

     

    • Inadequate reference to materials such as prior land use proposals, decisions, and rulings which pertain to the study area, or are inextricably linked to IfA-related Hawaiian Cultural Assessment issues.  For example, there are numerous instances where culturally relevant information is provided in the three documents cited below, but were not included in the ATST Cultural Assessment
    • The Cultural Assessment of Faulkes Telescope by McGuire and Hammatt, 2000.
    • The Kū i ka Mauna Traditional Practices Assessment by CKM, 2002.
    • T he Kü i ka Mauna Cultural Resources Evaluation by CKM, 2003.
    • Inadequate reference to the 2005 UH Institute for Astronomy Long Range Development Plan. Even though that document’s section on Hawaiian cultural practices contains some inaccuracies and insufficient specificity it still should have been cited in the cultural impact assessment for the ATST.
    • No or inadequate reference to the BLNR CDUA findings for Mauna Kea.  The Mauna Kea observatories are also under the auspices of the IfA. And, there are numerous similar cultural issues which can be found in the website:

     

    //www.kahea.org/maunakea/pdf/20051128_mk_hearing_findings_old.pdf

    • No or inadequate reference to Hawaiian genealogy indexes.

     

    • No or inadequate reference to Hawaiian Mähele, land court, census and tax records.
    • No or inadequate primary source materials consulted such as other previously published or recorded ethnographic interviews and oral histories, community studies, old maps, photographs, newspaper articles, and visitor journals regarding Haleakalä and especially the summit area.  For example, the Craigiela House visitor journal 4/23/1902 (at the Maui Historical Society), references a cave named Anamakauahi, a seven hour hike from Ulupalakua (south) up what is now known as the Skyline Trail, perhaps near Kolekole. Further research may uncover historically relevant materials regarding Kolekole.  Also, inadequate discussion, especially regarding the Upcountry Community Plan and other Maui County Plans, Bishop Museum and Maui Historical Society Photo Collections, or Hawaiian Language Newspaper articles referencing Haleakalä.

     

    • Inadequate reference to secondary source materials such as historical, sociological, and anthropological texts, manuscripts, and similar materials regarding Haleakalä and especially the summit area.  As examples:
    • No use or reference to Martha W. Beckwith’s Hawaiian Mythology, and references therein to demigod Māui exploits in Hawai`i and Oceania; especially relating to slowing the sun.

     

    • No use or reference to Elspeth P. Sterling’s Sites of Maui, with its extensive references to Mäui/Maui/Haleakalä and relevant bibliography.
    • No or inadequate reference to heretofore published legends. See previously mentioned Faulkes assessment by McGuire and Hammatt and their research on “Legends That Mention Haleakalä.”  It includes approximately 50 stories from at least 10 different sources; listed by story topic.

     

    • None or inadequate use of Pan-Pacific literature from Mangareva, New Zealand, Tahiti, Tonga, and Samoa referencing the related exploits of the demigod Mäui.
    • Inadequate use of dictionaries for place names and inadequate consistency regarding definitions of cultural use terminology.  All scholastic Hawaiian dictionaries are available online at //www.wehewehe.org

     

    • No references to proverbs and poetical sayings regarding Haleakalä to confirm cultural importance.  See Pukui Ölelo Noeau.
    • Inadequate references to other Hawaiian deities such as Poliahu, Käne, Kü, Lono, or Kanaloa in their sun, wind, rain, snow, plant, bird, insect, etc. forms and the attendant religious, spiritual, and cultural importance to the project area

     

    • No or inadequate reference to spiritual connection to sky father/earth mother (Wäkea and Papa) and therefore connection to atmosphere (lewa lani), mountaintops, and land masses of the entire archipelago.
    • No discussion of the 1961 Executive Order of then Governor Quinn:  “So long as Government Survey Triangulation Station “Kolekole” remains in use, there shall not be erected any structure exceeding in height to obstruct or to block the lines of sight from said Station.”  Also, inadequate discussion of implications of the Executive Order to historical, present, and possible future IfA (or other user) fees connected to HO in context of Native Hawaiian Ceded Lands trust for cultural preservation or other uses.  For example, most recently, Pan STARR 1’s consortium will contribute $10 million dollars for its operation.  Why no discussion on possibilities for Hawaiian cultural revitalization via consortium user fees?  //www.hawaii.edu/cgi-bin/uhnews?20061003170512

     

    • No interviews were conducted with previous interviewees or any Hawaiian Studies faculty of the University of Hawai’i system.
    • Inadequate discussion of the impact to the view plane looking up the mountain from Department of Hawaiian Homes Lands at Kahkikinui.  There is no rendering of the proposed ATST from Kahikinui or other places along Southeast Maui coastline where current Mees Solar Observatory can be seen and where ATST will be seen by native Hawaiians.

     

    • The conclusion of the cultural impact report needs clarification.  For example, the first paragraph is contradictory.  The first sentence states “any building…is an intrusion on the sacredness and spirituality…” but then the second sentence states, “One must find the balance of building.…”?  Can one either build on sacred ground or not?  The conditions for such activity are not articulated.  The quotation “…protect at best the cultural impact and methods used to mitigate these impacts.” needs re-wording or clarification.  It reads that the impact and methods used to mitigate the impacts need to be protected; not the culture.  The second paragraph assumes saying prayers to Pele will mitigate impact of digging into her kinolau. (Kinolau is the Hawaiian word for the form(s) a Hawaiian deity might assume.  One of Pele’s forms is lava.)  That is untrue and unacceptable in Pele worship.  Paragraph three assumes construction will take place and so mitigation includes awareness of cultural rules by taking sense of place classes.  The conclusion assumes mitigation is a forgone conclusion and does not allow for the no action alternative; another possible solution.  If the cultural concerns are, in fact, of great sacred significance, it is inappropriate to not list no action as a possible solution.  The last paragraph also assumes mitigation, but does not articulate in detail how all the rock should be handled when moved and re-sited.  Not all of the ~ 4,500 cubic feet of rock could fit on Reber circle.  The conclusion does not state the conditions to be imposed on use/protection of the rest of the rock/soil when moved.  Can the IfA move rock/soil to build another structure?  Will rock/soil placed in any other area of HO remain there in perpetuity?
    • Eight (8) of the 24 bibliographic references are duplications.

     

     

    In addition to the Cultural Resource Evaluation and Traditional Practices report, we raise these issues in the DEIS:

    • No discussion of IfA/Hawaiian cultural shared governance of HO in context of Ceded Lands.

     

    • No discussion of a Master Plan for the entire mountain, not just a Long Range Development Plan for the Ifa’s use of 18.66 acres.  As the IfA Self-Study of 2001 indicates, “The UH and the IfA have not been required to generate a multi-use Mauna Kea-style “master plan.”
    • Inadequate discussion of the cumulative effect of the current uses inside HO; and the communications, television, Coast Guard and other structures of the summit area.  National Park and Commercial (horse tours, bike tours, tourists, etc.) use impacting Native Hawaiian as they attempt to use the summit for spiritual/religious purposes cannot be overemphasized.

     

    • Inadequate discussion of possible impact on areas/property owners adjoining HO from a Hawaiian cultural perspective.
    • No or inadequate discussion of place names use for the summit; especially USGS quadrant versus ahupua`a, pointed out in the testimony by Mary Evanson in Vol. II Appendices of DEIS.

     

    • No discussion of parking for cultural practitioners w/in HO if more than 2-3 people are in attendance at ceremonies at either or both of the two shrines.

    In summary, there is overall lack of inadequate adherence to the June 2004 Hawai`i State Guidelines for Assessing Cultural Impacts of the Office of Environmental Quality Control (OEQC).  Also, there is ample evidence that the Cultural Assessment is inadequate in providing enough information to compel a reader to clearly understand the spiritual sacredness and cultural relationship of Hawaiians to Haleakalā as a whole; and the summit area in particular.  Finally, it is my personal opinion that there is an awkward bias on the part of the authors of the Cultural Assessment, apparent in their language and conclusion that does not seem appropriate when assessing a cultural impact.

    Haleakalā National Park Impacts

    A major deficiency of the DEIS is the inadequate treatment of the effects of the ATST on the Haleakalā National Park.  The National Park Service will be contributing its own comments on the DEIS.  However, I would like to reinforce their concerns.  The DEIS has trivialized the impact of the ATST with only minor references to the disruption to the view corridors and no mention of the reduced quality of the tourist experience.  The Red Hill lookout is the highest point on Haleakalā.  The proposed ATST site is a mere 1,500 feet from Red Hill where approximately one million tourists come each year to view one of the most beautiful and unique views on the planet.  Even the astronauts who were planning to go to the moon came to this location because of its very special environment.  Unfortunately, the DEIS grossly underestimates the impact of the “in-your-face” 143 feet high telescope and the adjacent service building.  The Upcountry Community Plan states as a Land Use Policy (page 18):  “Recognize the value of open space, including agricultural lands and view planes to preserve the region’s rural character.”

    Furthermore, the Red Hill overlook is located within the 55 db noise contour emanating from the construction of the ATST.  Although this is shown on the map on page 4-50, and despite that this high noise level would be in “ exceedance of the state standard for maximum permissible daytime sound levels in class A zones”, the DEIS describes this as being “less than significant.”  It is not.

    These visual and oral disturbances (individually and in combination) of a major viewing site from a United States National Park are unacceptable, and definitely a most significant environmental impact.  The fact that the DEIS ignores or trivializes these impacts seriously undermines the quality of the entire document.

    Scoping Meetings

    There were problems with the scoping meetings the public was not well informed about the actual height of the telescope facility and the attached service building.  In fact, it appears that there was an actual attempt to mislead the public.  The photos and sketches shown to the public were all aerial shots which gave the impression that the telescope was actually shorter than the top of the mountain.  The telescope actually will rise to a height about 100′ above the highest natural point on the mountain.  Furthermore, when asked the height of the telescope at the scoping meeting, the figure given by the ATST spokesperson was approximately 93 feet; the actual height is approximately 50 percent greater.

    The height of the service building was not given, and I do not believe it is even given in the DEIS although it appears that it too would violate the 35′ height limitation imposed by the Upcountry Community Plan Ordinance.

    Because the public was misled on the height, it was less able to comment accurately on the enormous visual impact of the planned facility.  It was not until several weeks later that the Maui News reported accurately on the actual telescope height, too late for the scoping meetings.

    Land Ownership (p. 1-5)

    Absent from the discussion of ownership of these lands is the problems of “ceded lands.”  The DEIS indicates that the University of Hawaii was given these lands by Governor Quinn’s Executive Order # 1987.  The DEIS states on pages 1-5 that the University is now the “fee owner” of these lands.  What the DEIS neglects to point out is that the Hawaii State Governor may not have had the right to give away these lands in 1961 since neither he nor the State of Hawaii owned the lands.  The lands at the summit of Haleakalā are “ceded lands” which have numerous implications, not the least of which is the need by users to pay rent.  Furthermore, the courts may rule someday that users of these lands may need to pay reparations to the Hawaiian Kingdom that was overthrown in January 1893 by United States naval forces.

    Coastal Zone Management Act, Chapter 205A, Hawaii Revised Statutes (p. 1-27)

    Section 1.7.3 states in the last sentence that the “HO complex would not be the Coastal Zone Management Area (CZMA).”  The entire state of Hawaii is in the coastal zone for purposes of the CZMA.  The proposed project is not in the Special Management Area (SMA) as delineated under the CZMA.  The SMA is a strip of land along the coast and some streams usually up to 1000’ from the shoreline.  There are additional permit requirement placed on proposed projects in the SMA.  The proposed ATST is not in the SMA.

     

     

    Department of Health Environmental Planning Office (p. 1-27 to 1-28)

    The paragraph in section 1.7.5 describes the Office of Environmental Quality Control, an Office placed in the Department of Health for administrative purposes.  The Environmental Planning Office is a separate part of the Department of Health.  The heading of this section should be retitled Office of Environmental Quality Control.

    Site Selection (p. 2-1)

    There are two separate problems with regards to the selection of sites:

    • Although the literature provided at one of the scoping meetings indicated that there were advantages to constructing a ground-based telescope instead of a space-based telescope on a satellite, the DEIS neglected to even consider a space-based telescope as a potential site.  It would seem that a space-based telescope would have many of the advantages which were found at Haleakalā and would avoid the need for adaptive optics.  A space-based solar telescope should be included in the Final EIS as an alternative site.

     

    • The DEIS has limited its evaluation only to the 18 acre site operated by the UH IfA. The DEIS then attempts to make a careful analysis between two almost similar sites, both in the 18 acre HO location.  Consequently, a potentially superior site, perhaps in the saddle to the Southwest of the 18 acre site, was not even considered and certainly was not evaluated.  This alternative site could potentially avoid many of the visual problems of being located so close to the Haleakalā National Park.  The site also may avoid some of the problems with Hawaiian cultural sites.  It was not even investigated.

    Placement of Excess Soil (p. 2-23 to 2-26)

    There seems to be some confusion as to what will happen with the excavated soil from the proposed site. On pages 2-24 and 2-26, it is suggested that it will be deposited at site A.  However, site A has been given two different functions:  as a site for soil placement and as the “construction staging” area.  Which is it?

    East and West Ahu (p. 3-6 to 3-10)

    The description and construction technique are related in many places in Sections 1, 2 and 3 of the DEIS.  In the space of the above cited pages, they are mentioned three separate times. Perhaps some of the redundancy can be reduced in the FEIS.

    Infrastructure and Utilities (p. 4-42)

    In the Executive Summary (ES 23 & 24) and on page 4-42 an upgrade to the MECO substation is mentioned.  No mention is made as to who will pay for this upgrade.  Will the burden fall on the general population of Maui who will see the capital cost of MECO rise, plus a subsequent increase in the community’s electric power rates?

    On this same page is a brief discussion of other projects in addition to the ATST:  Pan-STARRS; NASA Transportable Laser Ranging System; and the AEOS Mirror Coating Facility.  However, these proposed facilities are not discussed in subsequent section on their cumulative impacts.  They are all being built on the same land parcel with federal funding, and should be part of a discussion on cumulative impacts at the very least on electrical power generation and use.  The FEIS should address the cumulative impacts of these planned for facilities.

    Socioeconomic Impacts (p. 4-57 to 4-62)

    Aside from the reference on page 3-45 that tourism is Maui largest industry there seems to be little discussion of the potential for the proposed project to impact the industry.  Might not a large telescope detract from the visitor’s experience at the summit of Haleakalā, among the most visited sites on Maui?  There should be a discussion of the impacts on the visitor and any economic effect it might have on Maui’s tourism industry as a whole, in the FEIS.

    Appendix Reports

                The FEIS should contain the complete, unedited, transcripts from each of the scoping meetings held in 2005.  During those meetings much valuable testimony was given by the public; a recorder was present and took down all the comments verbatim.  Specifically, comments made at the meeting which are not included or reflected in the DEIS should be placed on the record in an appendix section in the FEIS.

     

    Thank you for the opportunity to review this Draft EIS.

    Sincerely,

     

    Peter Rappa
    Environmental Review Coordinator

     

    cc:        OEQC
    Dr. Charlie Fein, KC Environmental, Inc.
    Michael Maberry, University of Hawai‘i Institute for Astronomy
    James Moncur, WRRC
    Kiope Raymond
    Richard Mayer

  • Testimony by Dick Mayer

    To:   Dr. Craig Foltz, ATST Program Manager                                   October 22, 2006
             National Science Foundation, Division of Astronomical Sciences
             4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 10045, Arlington VA   22230
                             
    From:   Professor (Emeritus) Dick Mayer, Economics and Geography      Tel.808-878-1874
                  1111 Lower Kimo Dr.    Kula, Maui, HI   96790   dickmayer@earthlink.net

    RE:         FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)

    CONTENTS:
    I)   General comments
    II)  A list of issues and deficiencies that need to be addressed in a  FINAL .E.I.S. 

    I)  General Comments

    1) The views that I express below are my own and not necessarily those of any organization or association.

    2)  For many years I reviewed E.I.S. documents for the Environmental Center at UH Manoa.  During that period I rarely saw an E.I.S. that was so obviously unfair to the spirit of the E.I.S. legislation as this 2006 ATST D.E.I.S.  It is a one-sided defense of the proposed Solar Observatory.  It seems more the product of a hired P.R. firm.  The DEIS is a defense of the project’s impacts.  It was NOT an E.I.S., as envisaged in the original enabling legislation.   (Or, as the DEIS states on several occasions when there is an unmitagated problem, “that’s only a ‘subjective’ opinion.”)

    I had hoped that this 2006 Federal/State D.E.I.S. would be an unbiased assessment.  Unfortunately, the sheer size of the document in no way reflects a quality assessment of the environmental impact of the proposed project.  In fact, the D.E.I.S. makes it very difficult for reviewers to detect the actual environmental impact of the proposed project.

     

     FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)  – Dick Mayer      Page 2

    II)  A  list of issues that need to be further discussed or included in a  FINAL .E.I.S.

    1.               SCOPEING MEETINGS   There were problems with the scopeing meetings: the public was not well informed about the actual height of the telescope facility and the attached service building.  In fact, it appears that there was an actual attempt to mislead the public. The photos and sketches shown to the public were all aerial shots which gave the impression that the telescope was actually shorter than the top of the mountain. (The telescope actually will rise to a height about 100′ above the highest natural point on the mountain!!)  Furthermore, when asked the height of the telescope at the scopeing meeting, the figure given by the ATST spokesperson was approximately 93 feet; the actual height is approximately 50 percent greater.

    The height of the service building was not given, and I do not believe it is even given in the DEIS although it appears that it too would violate the 35′ height limitation imposed by the Upcountry Community Plan Ordinance.

    Because the public was mislead on the height, it was less able to comment accurately on the enormous visual impact of the planned facility.  It was not until several weeks later that the Maui News reported accurately on the actual telescope height, too late for the scopeing meetings.

    2.      SITE SELECTION    There are two separate problems with regard to the selection of sites:
    A) Although the literature provided at one of the scopeing meetings indicated that          there were advantages to constructing a ground-based telescope instead of a          space-based telescope on a satellite, the DEIS neglected to even consider a space-         based telescope as a potential site.  It would seem that a space-based telescope would have many of the advantages          which were found at Haleakala and would avoid the need for adaptive          optics.  A space-based solar telescope should BE included in the Final EIS as an          alternative site.
    FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)  – Dick Mayer      Page 3

    B) The DEIS has limited its evaluation only to the 18 acre site operated by the UH          IfA. The DEIS then attempts to make a careful analysis between two almost similar
    sites, both in the 18 acre HO location.  Consequently, a potentially superior site,
    perhaps in the saddle to the Southwest of the 18 acre site, was not even          considered and certainly was not evaluated.  This alternative site could potentially          avoid many of the visual problems of being located so close to the Haleakala          National Park.  The site also may avoid some of the problems with Hawaiian          cultural sites.  It was not even investigated.

    3.      HEAT AVOIDANCE CAUSING EXCESSIVE HEIGHT   Despite the fact that since 1996 there has been a 35′ height limit in the Upcountry Community Plan district, the proposed telescope would violate this ordinance.  It would be the tallest building in Maui County.  The DEIS describes the telescope’s “143 feet height” as being necessary to avoid being too close to the ground where there is considerable heat coming off of the dark lava rock.

    In literature supplied at one of the scopeing meetings it was mentioned that a potential solution to the considerable ground heat would be the installation of a white apron extending approximately 10 meters from the telescope’s base.  It is further stated that this white apron would provide numerous other benefits, such as containing spilt lubricating oil and collecting water runoff.

    Unfortunately, this white apron was not discussed in the DEIS.  If it had been included in the building design, evaluated and discussed, it might be possible to reduce the height of the telescope, maybe also the proposed illegally tall service building, and perhaps even the overall cost of the project.  If the white apron were built, what would be the telescope height needed?

    4.               SPIRITUAL AND CULTURAL” SIGNIFICANCE    I will limit my own comments about the “spiritual and cultural” significance of the Haleakala Summit site because so many others with far more knowledge will be commenting on this matter.  However, I would encourage those who are evaluating the FEIS,
     FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)  – Dick Mayer      Page 4

    to consider their own personal reaction if this telescope was being proposed to be     located on the Mall in Washington D.C. in front of the Lincoln Memorial, or perhaps
    at a site considered sacred to members of their own religion, such as on Calvary          Hill in the city of Jerusalem, or besides the Wailing Wall also in Jerusalem, or in the
    city of Mecca.  (Why would these sites not even be considered as potential
    locations for a grand scientific experiment that might benefit all of humankind?)

    5.      LAND OWNERSHIP   When discussing the ownership of these lands, the DEIS indicates that the University of Hawaii was given these lands by Gov. Quinn’s  Executive Order # 1987.  The DEIS states on P. 1-5 that the U. H. Is now the “fee owner” of these lands.

    What the DEIS neglects to point out is that the Hawaii State Governor may not have had the right to give away these lands in 1961 since neither he nor the State of Hawaii owned the lands.  The lands at the summit of Haleakala are “ceded lands” which have numerous implications, not the least of which is the need by users to pay rent.  Furthermore, the courts may rule someday that users of these lands may need to pay reparations to the Hawaiian Kingdom that was overthrown in January 1893 by United States naval forces.

    6.      OFF-SITE CONNECTIONS AND CUMULATIVE EFFECTS   Several references are made in the DEIS to connections to off-site facilities.  The references are to some kind of “base” for communication (p. 3-39) & (p. 4-43), to an off-site computer “server”, and to a vague facility where many of the telescope’s workers will be employed.  Although the DEIS refers to these locations, there is no description or evaluation of these off-site locations. In fact, the DEIS says on page 4-43 that “The details of the connectivity have not yet been determined.”  How then can the DEIS claim in the same section that there is “NO IMPACT”?

    Is the connectivity referring to the military’s computer located in Kihei (South Maui)?  To the Waiakoa Astronomy facility?  To the new astronomy building being constructed in Kula Malu? All of these locations?  Or none of them?
     FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)  –  Dick Mayer   Page 5

    Until the cumulative impacts of this project and its relation to other sites and over  whose lands are understood, the EIS will be incomplete.  For example, is the design and construction of the Kihei-Upcountry Highway connecting the ATST telescope to its military computer actually a portion of this project?

    7.               MILITARY RELATED COMPONENTS and SECURITY IMPLICATIONS     In several places within the DEIS, there are indications that there may be military connections to this project.  For example, there is a discussion of communication links via a fiber optic cable.  Does this mean that this telescope will be digitally tied to the military computer located in Kihei (South Maui)?  There is also mention made that the telescope will occasionally be serviced by the Air Force’s Mirror Coating Facility which is located at the Hawaii Observatory.  Finally, the scientific results from the ATST’s observation and analysis of the “solar mass ejections” and solar wind would be of great use to the United States’ emerging “militarization of space”.  Is the ATST actually part of the federal government’s military program?

    The close ties of the ATST to the military will result in potential security concerns for the facility, the workers, the “connections” to other facilities, and one million plus tourists who visit the area.  Security issues must be addressed in the Final EIS.

    8.               SCOPEING MEETING TRANSCRIPTS ARE ABSENT   The final EIS should contain the complete, unedited, transcripts from each of the scopeing meetings held in 2005.  During those meetings much valuable testimony was given by the public; a recorder was present and took down all the comments verbatim.

    Specifically, I made comments at the meeting which are not included or reflected in the DEIS.  Some of my comments are reflected in this letter; some are not, and should be placed on the record.

     

     FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)   –  Dick Mayer    Page 6

    9.               ELECTRICITY UPGRADES AND THE MAUI RESIDENTS    In the Executive Summary (ES 23 & 24) and on page 4-42 an upgrade to the MECO substation is mentioned.  No mention is made as to who will pay for this upgrade.  Will the burden fall on the general population of Maui who will see the capital cost of MECO rise, plus a subsequent increase in the community’s electric power rates?

    10.               CUMULATIVE IMPACTS FROM OTHER NEW ACTIVITIES    Page 4-42 indicates that there are other projects in addition to the ATST: Pan-STARRS; NASA Transportable Laser Ranging System; and the AEOS Mirror Coating Facility.  However, the DEIS is notably and very significantly silent on the cumulative impacts of these other projects and their interaction with the ATST.  They are all being built on the same land parcel with federal funding, and there is NO DESCRIPTION OF CUMULATIVE IMPACTS (except for a new electric substation).  None.  There is also the nearby federally funded 100 foot Homeland Security tower.

    Are there traffic concerns?  Biological considerations?  Cultural considerations? Disrupted view corridors?  Etc.  The final EIS should address these issues.  Does each of them have a CDUA?

     11.               HALEAKALA NATIONAL PARK IMPACTS   A major deficiency of the DEIS is the inadequate treatment of the effects of the ATST on the Haleakala National Park.  The National Park Service will be contributing its own comments on the DEIS.  However, I would like to reinforce their concerns. The DEIS has trivialized the impact of the ATST with only minor references to the disruption to the view corridors and no mention of the reduced quality of the tourist experience.

    The Red Hill lookout is the highest point on Haleakala.  The proposed ATST site is a mere 1,500 feet from Red Hill where approximately one million tourists come each year to view one of the most beautiful and unique views on the planet.  Even the astronauts who were planning to go to the moon came to this location because

     FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)   –  Dick Mayer    Page 7

    of its very special environment.  Unfortunately, the DEIS grossly underestimates the impact of the “in-your-face” 143 feet high telescope and the adjacent service building.  The Upcountry Community Plan states as a Land Use Policy (P. 18),“Recognize the value of open space, including agricultural lands and view planes to preserve the region’s rural character.”

    Furthermore, the Red Hill overlook is located within the 55 db noise contour emanating from the construction of the ATST.  Although this is shown on the map on page 4 – 50, and despite that this high noise level would be in “ exceedance of the state standard for maximum permissible daytime sound levels in class A zones”, the DEIS describes this as being “less than significant”!  It is NOT.

    These visual and oral disturbances (individually and in combination) of a major viewing site from a United States National Park are unacceptable, and definitely a  most significant environmental impact.  The fact that the DEIS ignores or trivializes these impacts seriously undermines the quality of the entire document.

    12.    SUPER WHITE REFLECTIVE PAINT    There is a reference to the super white paint being utilized on the telescope.  However I could find no discussion of the impact of that white paint on the visibility of the telescope.  In discussions during the scopeing, it was pointed out that the white paint would be “extremely reflective”, much more so than the neighboring AEOS telescope.  Consequently, the visual impact of the 143 feet high ATST will be amplified by its reflected radiance.  The final EIS must report on this affect.

    13.               ECONOMIC IMPACTS ON MAUI’S TOURIST INDUSTRY  It is expected that an EIS will examine carefully the economic impacts of a  proposed project.  The ATST DEIS is woefully lacking in economic analysis.  It does not even describe the major basic economic activity on Maui, the industry which brings in most of the income and provides most of the jobs, namely tourism.  I could not find in the entire DEIS even a single reference to tourism, tourist employment, and tourism dependency.

     

      FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)   –  Dick Mayer    Page 8

    (The employment figures on Page 3 – 46 hide, rather than point out, the significant and vital role of tourism.)

    If the tourism industry had been accurately considered in the DEIS, it would have indicated that Maui Island has for many years been considered the “Number One” tourist destination island in the whole world. (See last ten years of Conde Nastmagazine’s selections.)  Tourists come to Maui for both the special cultural experience as well as the incredible scenic beauty of the island.  The summit of Haleakala is probably the most visited spot on the island, and  at the summit lookout the ATST will be a direct assault on that tourist experience.  There will be consequences: a serious erosion of the visual experience.  This is not just some mere “subjective” observation, as the DEIS attempts to portray the view plane.  It is why more than a million people each year come to see the views.  It is why there is a substantial Haleakala summit tour business.

    Moreover, the tranquility of the overlook will be engulfed by the nearby construction noise.  And finally, and not insignificantly, tourist traffic up the mountain will be seriously impacted by the very heavy, slow-moving concrete trucks that will be unable to pull-over to allow a long line of tourist cars to pass.  (Only vague mitigative measures are provided.)

    All of these effects will impact the quality of Maui’s tourism industry.  Consequently, there may be fewer tourists coming to Maui, less money being spent and less jobs available.  It is inappropriate that the DEIS has totally neglected to even mention this, Maui’s major industry.  I expect the Final EIS to comprehensively study the impact of the ATST on the tourist experience and tourist industry.

    In this regard the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan states (P. 12),  “this Community Plan region is the home of significant resources, including water shed areas and the Haleakala National Park, which is significant in terms of its resource preservation, enhancement and protection values. From an economic standpoint, the National Park is viewed as an important component of the region’s economy.”

     

      FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)   –  Dick Mayer    Page 9

    14.               EXCAVATED SOIL  On pages 2 – 24 and 2 – 26 there seems to be some confusion as to what will happen with the excavated soil from the proposed site.  It is suggested that it will be deposited at site A.  However site A has been given two different functions: as a site for soil placement, and as the “construction staging” area .  Which is it?

    15.               RESIDENT AND COMMUNITY PREFERENCE FOR RURAL AMBIENCE  There is a strong feeling among residents in the surrounding community that this area should NOT be impacted by urban, large or industrial-type facilities.  These feelings have been expressed in the vision of the Kula Community Association (which includes the ATM site within its community).  The KCA vision statement reads as follows: “The vision of the Kula Community Association is to preserve open space, support agriculture, maintain a rural residential atmosphere, and to work together as a community.”

    These sentiments also form a basis for the legally adopted and enforceable (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan which governs the use of land in the region which includes the summit of Haleakala and the ATST site.  It states as a problem (P. 11),  “LOSS OF RURAL CHARACTER.  One of the primary attributes which make the Makawao-Pukalani-Kula region unique to the island is the rural and serene environment which defines Upcountry Maui’s character. The loss of this rural ambiance is of significant concern to the region’s residents.”

    As a Policy and Objective under Economic Activity, it states on page 17,“Recognize the rural, open space character of the Upcountry region as an economic asset of the island.”

    16.               MASTER PLAN FOR THE WHOLE SUMMIT AND FOR ALL THE ACTIVITIES  The (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan which governs the use of land in the region that includes the ATST site, the whole UH IfA site, the Haleakala summit, and the Haleakala National Park indicates the direction for use of the environment.  It states clearly on Page 24 as the Goal for the Environment,
    FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)   –  Dick Mayer    Page 10

    “ENVIRONMENT  Goal    Protection of  Upcountry’s natural resources and environment as a means of preserving and enhancing the region’s unique beauty, serenity, ecology, and productivity, in order that future generations may enjoy and appreciate an environment of equal or higher quality.”

    To achieve this Goal, it specifies an Objective and Policy (P. 25),  “Encourage Federal, State and County cooperation in the preparation of a comprehensive Haleakala summit master plan to promote orderly and sensitive development which is compatible with the natural and native Hawaiian cultural environment of Haleakala National Park.”

             In the year 2001 the Maui County Council passed Resolution 01-45 entitled, “Urging the State of Hawaii to Fund Master Planning for Haleakala”.   Unfortunately, to-date the Master Plan is only for the 18 acre IfA site.  There is an obvious need to plan not just the IfA 18 acres, but the whole summit region of Haleakala.  Only in this way will the interaction among the various activities be known and the problems mitigated.  It is equally obvious that this DEIS has yet to grasp the multiple impacts of the ATST on other activities at the summit.

    17.    35-FOOT HEIGHT LIMITATION THROUGHOUT THE REGION   The height and the scale of the proposed 143′ ATST facility and the approximately 70′ adjoining service building violate an important design guideline contained within the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan.  In fact, the DEIS totally ignores this guideline, perhaps because its impact can NOT be mitigated by the proposed project.  The guideline (Page 30) reads as follows, “Enforce a two-story or 35-foot height limitation throughout the region, except for public/quasi-public uses such as auditoriums, gymnasiums, and fire stations.”

    Since I was vice chairman of the Citizens Advisory Committee that recommended the restrictive guideline, I know that the guideline clearly applies to the ATST facility.

     

    FEDERAL/STATE  D.E.I.S. — ATST (Haleakala Solar Observatory)     –  Dick Mayer    Page 11

             Although it is a publically owned facility, it is not one needed by the general public as do those in the examples given (auditoriums, gymnasiums, and fire stations).

             Since the Community Plan is a Maui County ordinance and because a CDUA permit requires that every application must conform to ALL State and County ordinances, the ATST would be ineligible to receive a CDUA permit from DLNR.  (NOTE: Neighboring HO telescopes, such as the 110′ AEOS telescope were permitted before the adoption of the 35′ maximum in the 1996 Community Plan.)

     

    Mahalo for your consideration of these comments; I look forward to the Final EIS response.

    Sincerely,

     

    Prof. (Emeritus) Richard “Dick” Mayer
    1111 Lower Kimo Dr.    Kula, Maui, HI   96790    dickmayer@earthlink.net

     

     

    PERSONAL NOTE    Thank you for your attention to and response to these concerns.  The rural atmosphere of the Upcountry region is cherished by Upcountry residents whose wishes are clearly expressed in the (Upcountry) Makawao-Pukalani-Kula Community Plan, as well as in the Kula Community Association vision.

     

    CC.  Office of Environmental Quality Control,  Hawai’I Dept. of Health
    Mr. Mike Mayberry,  UH IfA
    Dr. Charles Fein,  KC Environmental Inc.
    Mr. Michael Foley,  Maui County Planning Department